• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Horizon: Zero Dawn | Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
M

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
KAL2006 said:
Gravity Rush 2
Nioh
Yakuza 0
Horizon
Nier
Persona 5
Gran Turismo Sport
Uncharted Lost Legacy
Knack 2
Ni No Kuni 2
Hellblade

Maybe one of the following for Q4?
Days Gone
Detroit
Dreams
God of War

I've removed the remasters even the Crash remake. And the lineup is still insane. For me personally Horizon and Uncharted Lost Legacy and Persona 5 make the year. Also note I haven't included super niche games like Tales of Berseria or indie exclusives
Click to expand...

Again I agree with you and in fact I'd keep crash because it's more of a full-blown remake than just a touchup like 2.8 or even when people were including gow3r or tlour .

I may have remembered wrong though isn't no no Kuni going to PC?
 
K

KAL2006

Banned
Papacheeks said:
Hope they make a sequel with Aloy.

Would they have a separate team to be able to have them work on Killzone with what they learned from this game?

Feel like a open world style third person killzone game with tactics could be really cool in the killzone universe especially if they take it to other planets with alien life.

or after this game being a success which I'm certain it will, are they done with that for a while and concentrating on this series if it does continue?
Click to expand...

If this is a sales success no doubt Guerrilla will make 2 more sequels at the least. Horizon has a expansive world and alot of lore. I'm sure they can milk this IP way more. We all thought Last of Us was going to be a standalone game but sales success has managed to make Naughty Dog make a sequel.
 
M

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
KAL2006 said:
If this is a sales success no doubt Guerrilla will make 2 more sequels at the least. Horizon has a expansive world and alot of lore. I'm sure they can milk this IP way more. We all thought Last of Us was going to be a standalone game but sales success has managed to make Naughty Dog make a sequel.
Click to expand...

I think tlou2 was always being considered.

Edit- also I'm glad for GG to get this chance. Honestly they needed to move on from kz imo. I got to talk with a few of them at a bar after the reveal and they were so confident and excited to show what they had in store.
 
D

demogorgon

Banned
Blackleg-sanji1 said:
I'm confused did I miss a console war Should i go back a few pages? What was the point of this
Click to expand...

not at all. just showing both sides of the coins. there are people who believe one console has crap and the other has a wealth of games. the reality is both have plenty of good games for everyone. look at the post i replied to ;)
 
D

demogorgon

Banned
KAL2006 said:
D4, Gigantic, Dead Rising, Record, Ryse were below average. Halo 5 and Gears haven't reviewed as well as Uncharted 4.

Peoples aren't listing games like Tales of Berseria, Killzone Shadowfall, inFamous Second Son and The Order to make a point.

People are listing games like Bloodborne, Persona 5, Nioh, Horizon to state that Sony are releasing not only more exclusives bit higher reviewed exclusives.
Click to expand...

I never said what was good or bad. it's all pretty subjective. I was just replying to someone who said "unlike MS who only focuses on one game "halo"

Even if the output is bad in someones eyes, it's still a wide variety of stuff.

The system wars posts on here are ridiculous. IDK why people can't enjoy one thing without putting down another

Personally As someone who has a PC, PS4, and XB1 i enjoy all the variety and games I get. IDK why others can't be that way
 
K

Khalifa Jayy

Banned
Maroon Gamer said:
http://www.vg247.com/2017/02/20/hor...had-a-baby-and-it-deserves-to-win-your-heart/

Horizon Zero Dawn is going to make other open-world developers sick with envy.

It is The Witcher 3 of post-post-apocalyptic robo-dino adventures; it is the sort of thing Ubisoft will wish you had never seen if it dares to release another time-sucking, glitch-filled Assassin’s Creed.

This is very probably the most flawless open world game ever made.
Click to expand...

DAMN.

That is some incredible praise, and beautiful shots fired haha.
 
D

demogorgon

Banned
SG-17 said:
Aren't those all coming out on PC too?
Click to expand...

iMax said:
None of the titles listed here hold a candle to Sony's exclusive catalogue, at least from category-defining, industry-shifting standpoint. That is what Microsoft needs to find.
Click to expand...

onemanasylum said:
What is the point of this? You are only highlighting the differences between the two.
Click to expand...

u know what, never mind. you guys keep doing what you do. I'm just throwing all the fanboys on ignore so i can enjoy the forums and discuss games with actual gamers
 
M

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
demogorgon said:
u know what, never mind. you guys keep doing what you do. I'm just throwing all the fanboys on ignore so i can enjoy the forums and discuss games with actual gamers
Click to expand...

Man just don't even get into it. The console wars are everywhere I've learned to just let it go. To them seeing games review well or turn out great isn't about great or fun games, it's to stroke their ego which is for whatever reason tied to their console of choice.
 
R

RefigeKru

Banned
I've been playing Guerrilla games since the first Killzone so these reviews are amazing to see. So glad to see them getting the recognition they deserve.
 
M

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
The Lamp said:
Depends on what you liked about TW3. The side quests here are not as creative and the game is not as long as TW3.
Click to expand...

Pretty much everything in tw3 tbh, but yeah the side quests in there were unreal. No fetch quests or filler, each quest was engaging and fun. Most of the time sidequests can be a drag in games. Infamous imo was a good series held back from great by awful fetch quests and repetitive stuff.
 
K

KORNdoggy

Member
The Lamp said:
Depends on what you liked about TW3. The side quests here are not as creative and the game is not as long as TW3.
Click to expand...

...But the world is more interesting and the combat is light years better.

I'm not sure TW3's side quests are even that creative either really. They just wrapped them in some really nice narrative.
 
B

BaasRed

Banned
Since the game seems to be around 30 hours I will probably buy it on release. Im happy a game with such aesthetic and style exists bow :)
 
D

demogorgon

Banned
msdstc said:
Man just don't even get into it. The console wars are everywhere I've learned to just let it go. To them seeing games review well or turn out great isn't about great or fun games, it's to stroke their ego which is for whatever reason tied to their console of choice.
Click to expand...

yup. i just added all them to ignore. it's that easy. I'll ignore the irrational fanboys. they are pretty easy to spot. then I can enjoy conversing with actual gamers. I'm sure most of them will get banned eventually anyway
 
P

Primethius

Banned
Is this thread about to devolve into a dumb list war, or has it already?

--
The Lamp said:
Depends on what you liked about TW3. The side quests here are not as creative and the game is not as long as TW3.
Click to expand...

I'm guessing for me, combat alone in Horizon will put it above TW3 just going off reviews and impressions.
 
S

Styles

Member
Always knew it was more akin to TW3.

Give it to me, GG.
gaycat3.png
 
Mikey Jr.

Mikey Jr.

Member
Yeah, the Witcher 3 combat was poor.

I always dreaded when I had to fight something. Also, it didn't run great on PS4 out of the gate. Took a couple of patches.

Also, its Witcher THREE. Give Guerilla a chance, haha. Witcher 1 was terrible.
 
L

LiquidSolid

Member
KAL2006 said:
If this is a sales success no doubt Guerrilla will make 2 more sequels at the least. Horizon has a expansive world and alot of lore. I'm sure they can milk this IP way more. We all thought Last of Us was going to be a standalone game but sales success has managed to make Naughty Dog make a sequel.
Click to expand...

No we didn't. I always thought a sequel would happen, especially once we found out Uncharted 4 would be the last Uncharted game Naughty Dog would make.
 
O

onemanasylum

Banned
P

pixellated_man

Member
T

The Lamp

Member
FYI the Collector's Edition is back up on Amazon.

I reinstated my pre-order. I love this game so much I want to buy a collector's copy at launch.
 
Y

Yurikerr

This post isn't by me, it's by a guy with the same username as me.
NotSmartEnough said:
Sorry, I got sidetracked responding to Servbot24's reply.

I think your examples of inexcusable content are likely to result in a game failing to get the relevant certification to even be released. Do you think that a game that tackled those themes in an inexcusable way would get as far as being reviewed?
Click to expand...

Thanks for you response and sorry for the late reply.

In relation to certification (I hope that) we can always have the PC ecosystem that support self publishing for better or worst.

Games like Hatred were published before and will continue to be made. It has almost 50 reviews registered on Metacritic, and one of them is a 7 out of 100. That to me is almost the same as a 0. The "positive" quote is this one:

Hatred, as a piece of transgressive art, is a failure. It's dull, its violence crass and unconvincing, and its understanding of humanity shallow at best. But it's worth looking at, if only to understand why, and if only to interrogate what, if anything, could be gained from peering closely at something so horrible.
Click to expand...

If you read the whole review you'll see that the reviewer make a lot of good points and explain really well why reviewing the game is important, even if the score is almost null.

But, I think there is a grey area there: What about Manhunt? Technically competent? What about the morality of the game? What about GTA? Ethically dubious? How many points do we deduct?
Click to expand...

The amount of points deducted is determined by each person. I may have a bigger aversion to a theme than you, because of personal preferences, life background, etc. Games aren't ever like "I like open world/I dislike FPS" and that's it.

I doubt we're going to agree, and I don't want to have a bad-tempered argument. I just think that a 0/10 review needs something solid on a technical front to back it up. Opinions are one thing, reviews are another.
Click to expand...

As I said, personally I have no problem with the scores of reviews, for me what needs to be judged is the content of it. if the person can articulate why he thinks the game deserves a high, low, perfect or zero score that's all that matters.

And don't worry about it turning into a bad-tempered argument, it's great to debate with others that have a different view about a subject (at least not because of me).

Bad7667 said:
Reviews are opinions. If you want a review to be nothing but facts it would no longer be recognizable from what we call reviews. And even taking your point into consideration, that the review needs to tackle the technical aspects of a game, that too would be opinion. Some people have zero problems with framerate drops and others find games that do completely unplayable.

Whenever you ask someone to review a product and give a score, it's in the opinion of the person who reviewed said product.
Click to expand...

I mostly agree with this.

Even pc parts reviews generally devolve into opinion territory. If reviews were 100% objective they would be simple feature sheets.
 
B

BlackBuzzard

Banned
Mikey Jr. said:
Yeah, the Witcher 3 combat was poor.

I always dreaded when I had to fight something. Also, it didn't run great on PS4 out of the gate. Took a couple of patches.

Also, its Witcher THREE. Give Guerilla a chance, haha. Witcher 1 was terrible.
Click to expand...

Not only that. Its their first open world action rpg and they seemed to have knocked it out of the park.
 
L

Loudninja

Member
Some high praise

Horizon Zero Dawn is an instant classic: tough, challenging, huge, incredibly fun to play. It's the new definition of the videogame in the most classical way, where the center of the experience is the genuine entertainment of the player. There are some minor flaws here and there, and the narrative isn't as strong as it could've been, but nonetheless, it's the best action game of this generation.
Click to expand...
http://www.thegamesmachine.it/horizon-zero-dawn/horizon-zero-dawn-recensione-ps4/

Even of it wasnt in and open world game the combat sounds amazing.
 
G

Ghandi

Banned
I am salty as fuck because I kept telling myself
"This game gunna suuck, I can gladly sell my ps4 and only play PC and switch from here on now, I only have to borrow a ps4 for uc4 dlc and tlou 2. The rest sucks dick and PC master raaace, and this gonna be a perfect symbol of a good looking but hollow POS game...go eat a duck ps4 pro"

(Bear with me, I didnt went to rl friends or any internet boards or comment sections and shat on their favourite console. I kept the struggel quiet lol. Unitl now. Well, now I want to write out why I feel that way. Not that I have an "actual" point why people shouldnt enjoy their console, far from it. )
(Also switch is gonna be alright for me because I see it as a handheld, so it is okay to exist besides my PC)

So yakuza 0 is fantastic, nioh is fantastic, horizon is fantastic and this bothers me, because after I switched to PC I noticed how much more the system fits me. How awesome discord is, how awesome it is to use a good PC for all my gaming needs, that I can use e.g. every music streaming service I want, not just spotify and the overall comfort and "freedom" is a thing a classic console cannot provide me with.


Because of this I secretly wish every game comes to PC and console exclusives are bothering as hell to me ATM.

Of course this is on the one hand petty, I mean pure pettyness. On the other it is my....uh..lustfull desire to stay on PC and feel like a champ doing it, still with a corporate thump up my bum, but less pronounced as when I am on ps4.


The newer exclusive titles for ps4 are ridiculous good and I am looking forward to play them as soon as I get to have time for them, but with a tear in one eye and a smile in the other.

TL;dr: I want to shit on ps4 because good ps4 exlusives give me the feeling that PC as a gaming platform is less awesome as I wish it could be but I know this is stupid behavoir so I dont do it, but I wish I could, I need an anonymous help therapy or something.
STILL: Congrats gg on this achievemnt and the technical praise also exites me. Good times for gaming!

And I hope this doesnt come across as trolling because it is meant to be the polar opposite. More of a self analysis
 
Mikey Jr.

Mikey Jr.

Member
KAL2006 said:
If this is a sales success no doubt Guerrilla will make 2 more sequels at the least. Horizon has a expansive world and alot of lore. I'm sure they can milk this IP way more. We all thought Last of Us was going to be a standalone game but sales success has managed to make Naughty Dog make a sequel.
Click to expand...

They are making Horizon 2. GG said just as much when they said Aloy might not be the protag in part 2.
 
M

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
pixellated_man said:
Wait...what the..that is some patronizing, hateful stuff. And to think, I was defending Nzyme earlier, based on the fact that he is usually quite a sensible poster. Not in that thread it seems.
The highly positive reception to the game must be annoying the hell out of them. Silly people.
Click to expand...

Are you really getting bent out of shape about this? The thoughts were split with some people saying it looked good, others saying it looked like a generic open world game. Hell nzymes post was completely benign. How is he not being sensible? He basically said he's not into that type of game but good for those who are.
 
M

MegaSackman

Member
KORNdoggy said:
...But the world is more interesting and the combat is light years better.

I'm not sure TW3's side quests are even that creative either really. They just wrapped them in some really nice narrative.
Click to expand...

You're right on the creative thing about The Witcher III, they're expertly written though. But you still have some quests of chasing goats and retrieve pans that I personally hate in every video game.
 
K

KAL2006

Banned
Ghandi said:
I am salty as fuck because I kept telling myself
"This game gunna suuck, I can gladly sell my ps4 and only play PC and switch from here on now, I only have to borrow a ps4 for uc4 dlc and tlou 2. The rest sucks dick and PC master raaace, and this gonna be a perfect symbol of a good looking but hollow POS game...go eat a duck ps4 pro"

(Bear with me, I didnt went to rl friends or any internet boards or comment sections and shat on their favourite console. I kept the struggel quiet lol. Unitl now. Well, now I want to write out why I feel that way. Not that I have an "actual" point why people shouldnt enjoy their console, far from it. )
(Also switch is gonna be alright for me because I see it as a handheld, so it is okay to exist besides my PC)

So yakuza 0 is fantastic, nioh is fantastic, horizon is fantastic and this bothers me, because after I switched to PC I noticed how much more the system fits me. How awesome discord is, how awesome it is to use a good PC for all my gaming needs, that I can use e.g. every music streaming service I want, not just spotify and the overall comfort and "freedom" is a thing a classic console cannot provide me with.


Because of this I secretly wish every game comes to PC and console exclusives are bothering as hell to me ATM.

Of course this is on the one hand petty, I mean pure pettyness. On the other it is my....uh..lustfull desire to stay on PC and feel like a champ doing it, still with a corporate thump up my bum, but less pronounced as when I am on ps4.


The newer exclusive titles for ps4 are ridiculous good and I am looking forward to play them as soon as I get to have time for them, but with a tear in one eye and a smile in the other.

TL;dr: I want to shit on ps4 because good ps4 exlusives give me the feeling that PC as a gaming platform is less awesome as I wish it could be but I know this is stupid behavoir so I dont do it, but I wish I could, I need an anonymous help therapy or something.
STILL: Congrats gg on this achievemnt and the technical praise also exites me. Good times for gaming!

And I hope this doesnt come across as trolling because it is meant to be the polar opposite. More of a self analysis
Click to expand...

What the hell did I just read
 
S

Slaythe

Member
Ghandi said:
I am salty as fuck because I kept telling myself
"This game gunna suuck, I can gladly sell my ps4 and only play PC and switch from here on now, I only have to borrow a ps4 for uc4 dlc and tlou 2. The rest sucks dick and PC master raaace, and this gonna be a perfect symbol of a good looking but hollow POS game...go eat a duck ps4 pro"

(Bear with me, I didnt went to rl friends or any internet boards or comment sections and shat on their favourite console. I kept the struggel quiet lol. Unitl now. Well, now I want to write out why I feel that way. Not that I have an "actual" point why people shouldnt enjoy their console, far from it. )
(Also switch is gonna be alright for me because I see it as a handheld, so it is okay to exist besides my PC)

So yakuza 0 is fantastic, nioh is fantastic, horizon is fantastic and this bothers me, because after I switched to PC I noticed how much more the system fits me. How awesome discord is, how awesome it is to use a good PC for all my gaming needs, that I can use e.g. every music streaming service I want, not just spotify and the overall comfort and "freedom" is a thing a classic console cannot provide me with.


Because of this I secretly wish every game comes to PC and console exclusives are bothering as hell to me ATM.

Of course this is on the one hand petty, I mean pure pettyness. On the other it is my....uh..lustfull desire to stay on PC and feel like a champ doing it, still with a corporate thump up my bum, but less pronounced as when I am on ps4.


The newer exclusive titles for ps4 are ridiculous good and I am looking forward to play them as soon as I get to have time for them, but with a tear in one eye and a smile in the other.

TL;dr: I want to shit on ps4 because good ps4 exlusives give me the feeling that PC as a gaming platform is less awesome as I wish it could be but I know this is stupid behavoir so I dont do it, but I wish I could, I need an anonymous help therapy or something.
STILL: Congrats gg on this achievemnt and the technical praise also exites me. Good times for gaming!

And I hope this doesnt come across as trolling because it is meant to be the polar opposite. More of a self analysis
Click to expand...

You can do what I do.

Buy a capture card with no delay and play the ps4 on PC. All the comfort and multi tasking of PC with the ps4 library.

It's the best of both world. Ps4pro waiting for Horizon :D Discord running in background. Audio streamed to pc. =)
 
V

Valentus

Member
Maroon Gamer said:
http://www.vg247.com/2017/02/20/hor...had-a-baby-and-it-deserves-to-win-your-heart/

Horizon Zero Dawn is going to make other open-world developers sick with envy.

It is The Witcher 3 of post-post-apocalyptic robo-dino adventures; it is the sort of thing Ubisoft will wish you had never seen if it dares to release another time-sucking, glitch-filled Assassin’s Creed.

This is very probably the most flawless open world game ever made.
Click to expand...


Really, gg should never touch killzone again and build their reputation un this IP.

Also, lol at that ubi slap
 
H

hardcastlemccormick

Banned
I'm caught off guard buy the comments that the game is "tough, challenging," but everything else sounds utterly fantastic. I'll probably pick this up.

I'm really glad the game is reviewing well. I was hoping it would be a winner.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered | Review Thread
Analysis Review 4 5 6 7 8
379
22K
kruis replied
Lego Horizon recasts Sylens, previously played by the late Lance Reddick
News
32
2K
Woopah replied
Horizon Online could be coming 1H 2025...
2 3
133
5K
Fabieter replied
Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered: A deep dive into its enhancements
News 2 3 4
189
11K
saintjules replied
Horizon Zero Dawn Remastered forces PSN login for PC users if they decide to upgrade
Platform 2 3 4
174
8K
awwr999999 replied
Top Bottom