And yet in many of these states, there are more than enough swing voters to overcome any boost in GOP turnout (which is likely to be small - didnt help Buck, ODonnell or Angle in GOP wave years!). And a Democrat is always preferable to a Republican.
I just think its wrong to look at the history of wave elections as a likely indicator. Using history to predict turnout is exactly why much of the polling prior to the election was wrong. Trump changes the map.
Yes there theoretically are enough swing voters to overcome a still energized base but its playing a risky game, considering how much of an advantage Trump has given the power of rural distribution in the house and senate.
Weve also never had a president like Trump before. Weve never had a presidency like this one before. Or a base that has stuck with a guy through as much as he has been through. Im not convinced turnout will be down, extremism of GOP nominees will be a turnoff, and democrats will capitalize on both those factors.
Really I think the safer option is to target the failure of Ryan and the establishment GOP. Targeting extremism and not accounting for what could be unusually high party wave turnout is potentially a terrible idea. Because I dont think anyone should rule out that rural turnout will be higher than what anyone could predict again, especially if the democratic strategy is to apparently hand republican voters who are turned on by extremists out.
They have single party control but many loyal republicans feel like they are being cheated out of it or arent getting what they wanted or were promised. I think this is different from most waves because the voters are likely going to blame the rinos rather than the president because he can do no wrong.
Id like to target swing voters but avoiding giving Trump loyalists options with things to run on has to be part of the strategy too. To me enabling extrism is just as bad of an idea as making a pied piper out of trump in 2016 rather than just tying him to typical republicans was. Its a bit tone deaf and isnt reading the room on what the would be voters would be turned on or off by.
Ryans approvals are a full 13 points lower than Trumps. So is McConnell. Theres more to work with by targeting that than enabling more Trumpism in what I think are completely untested political waters