-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Pushsquare, “Reaction: PS5 Livestreams Are No Longer Speaking to the Fans Who Built the Brand”
- Thread starter ArtHands
- Start date
Banjo64
cumsessed
Sony don’t owe their ‘legacy’ fans anything. To me Nintendo and Sony hand in hand was always the combination. My personal thoughts are that their current path is a narrow one, it doesn’t appeal to me personally, however it’s clearly the most profitable path for Sony.
They are still making games that I want to play: Ratchet and Clank, Sackboy, Returnal, Gran Turismo 7 and Astrobot. I know these will be high quality, polished games.
To be honest, seeing it listed out like that, makes me want to consider buying another PS5.
I think for me I’d happily leave Santa Monica’s output, and I wouldn’t touch anything TLoU, nor Insomniac’s Marvel. But there’s still enough there at this point to justify a purchase. Just my personal opinion but it’s the current direction of those 3 studios in particular that rankles.
They are still making games that I want to play: Ratchet and Clank, Sackboy, Returnal, Gran Turismo 7 and Astrobot. I know these will be high quality, polished games.
To be honest, seeing it listed out like that, makes me want to consider buying another PS5.
I think for me I’d happily leave Santa Monica’s output, and I wouldn’t touch anything TLoU, nor Insomniac’s Marvel. But there’s still enough there at this point to justify a purchase. Just my personal opinion but it’s the current direction of those 3 studios in particular that rankles.
midnightAI
Member
Wow, kneejerk reaction to a State of Play
Hero of Spielberg
Gold Member
It’s sad to see but as others have said it seems to be the way of the industry. Just look at the top played games on Twitch, it’s the same GaaS forever and everyone wants a bigger slice of the pie
GHG
Gold Member
Why must you have the worst takes on everything?
Look at a list of the best selling playstation exclusives from those generations you mentioned. What you said isn't remotely close to being true.
MacReady13
Member
100% spot on. They decided big budget was what they wanted. I’m all for story driven games but spending what they are is insane. Let’s get some more of those quirky, weird and fun games they used to make. They’ve lost the plot. Badly.
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Fat Jim is responsible for the move away from the core Playstation product, and into the realms of nonstop GaaS, and PC ports.
Mark my old man words… in a few years we’ll be dissecting the fall of PlayStation and blaming him the same way we blame Fatter Phil now for Xbox's demise.
Mark my old man words… in a few years we’ll be dissecting the fall of PlayStation and blaming him the same way we blame Fatter Phil now for Xbox's demise.
Last edited:
kyussman
Member
Surely the people that built the brand are aging out at this point,I was on board for the PS1 launch and I'm 51 in a few weeks......and yea,current gaming trends are unattractive to me,but it seems younger gamers are all in on GAAS and good multiplayer games.At this point I need AAA games to really innovate to get me excited to game,sequels and remakes aren't gonna bring me back to PlayStation,and as an older guy I'm also more sensitive to the woke ideology infecting gaming,again younger people seem conditioned to this nonsense and don't find it as offensive as I do,lol.....see sales of Spider-Man 2.
DryvBy
Member
Sony's first party has been abysmal and I'd say that for every company outside of Nintendo. And Nintendo isn't too far up my list either, given the Switch is mostly a remaster and remake showcase.
Every company needs to have more smaller projects going in between big ones. One thing Sony has done right is renting devs for 3rd party production on the platform. Stellar Blade is a legit terrific action game and an example of why I still enjoy this generation.
VitoNotVito
Member
Like what?
SJRB
Gold Member
What the fuck? No they don't, they need to expand and appeal to new generations without shunning the fans they already have.
Replacing instead of expanding is moronic.
Angry_Megalodon
Member
It's partially true.
The next 4 years of Hermen's tenure will be a good assessment of whether this trend consolidates or has some middle ground.
The two CEOs structure should prevent this.
The next 4 years of Hermen's tenure will be a good assessment of whether this trend consolidates or has some middle ground.
The two CEOs structure should prevent this.
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
So, a year where they have exclusive Silent Hill and FF7 titles, and are pushing a new Kojima joint coming soon isn't leaning hard on Playstation's past?
And of course their big holiday release is mascot platformer filled with call-backs to the platform and franchise characters...
This has been the most traditionalist Playstation line-up in a long, long, time.
Hell, this year generally has been the most JRPG-centric year in literally decades. Granblue, FF7r, Dragon's Dogma 2, Elden Ring DLC all in the first half of the year! Bolstered by character action games like Stellar Blade and Rise Of The Ronin...
Sorry but making contentions like the one in the OP really make me wonder whether these people have any affinity for Playstation historically whatsoever. Are they perhaps confusing it with Xbox? Where for decades their output was built around the same 3 or 4 annual or bi-annual franchises?
And of course their big holiday release is mascot platformer filled with call-backs to the platform and franchise characters...
This has been the most traditionalist Playstation line-up in a long, long, time.
Hell, this year generally has been the most JRPG-centric year in literally decades. Granblue, FF7r, Dragon's Dogma 2, Elden Ring DLC all in the first half of the year! Bolstered by character action games like Stellar Blade and Rise Of The Ronin...
Sorry but making contentions like the one in the OP really make me wonder whether these people have any affinity for Playstation historically whatsoever. Are they perhaps confusing it with Xbox? Where for decades their output was built around the same 3 or 4 annual or bi-annual franchises?
Lagspike_exe
Member
Era of many great, cinematic, single-player oriented games is long gone. Companies cannot afford to invest hundreds of millions of $ into games that cannot be monetized aside from buying the box.
King Dazzar
Member
Regardless of who are or aren't the core players who built the brand. I have no doubt Sony will not be happy with the generally negative feedback from the SoP as a whole. If Concord then fails to do well too.... I think it's great that Astro Bot got such a warm reception, if nothing else reminding them of what some of their customers love. Lets hope they kick things up a notch around Pro's release.
Bernardougf
Member
Sony really lucked out with microsoft completely shitting the bed this gen ... this gaas chasing nonsense would have been their doom if MS had their shit together and would be releasing great single player experiences, with the PRO consoles in the corner and this shit lineup sony has I would be very much tempted to say fuck you to ps5 pro and jump on the xbox pro (if it have existed). But in the chase of shitty trends MS chose the worst one with gamepass.. and now.. we have to content with Sony and their gaas... fucking horrible waist of money of a gen.
rhodesianshepard
Banned
You can't bitch about Playstation not having enough visually stunning games this generation while also stating that game development takes way too long. It doesn't compute
This year, Playstation could potentially release 3 exclusives as GOTY contenders(HD2,FF7R,Astro). If we talking about people who built the brand, this year does a great job encapsulating the variety the PS2 and PS3 used to offer
This year, Playstation could potentially release 3 exclusives as GOTY contenders(HD2,FF7R,Astro). If we talking about people who built the brand, this year does a great job encapsulating the variety the PS2 and PS3 used to offer
That some people cry online because they don't get the announcements they want when they want is pretty much irrelevant to them.
They need to cater to new audiences and have more successes like Helldivers2 and Destiny even if that's not what the old guard 35+years old fans want.
They have also not abandoned the old single player focused productions, Astrobot for example seems fantastic and among the best you can get in the platform genre.
It's just that these productions take 5-6 years to be developed and most of them will be ready deep into the second half of the PS5 lifecycle (which is not much different from what happened on PS4....people have really short memories and select what they want to remember).
They need to cater to new audiences and have more successes like Helldivers2 and Destiny even if that's not what the old guard 35+years old fans want.
They have also not abandoned the old single player focused productions, Astrobot for example seems fantastic and among the best you can get in the platform genre.
It's just that these productions take 5-6 years to be developed and most of them will be ready deep into the second half of the PS5 lifecycle (which is not much different from what happened on PS4....people have really short memories and select what they want to remember).
Last edited:
Hero of Spielberg
Gold Member
We can only hope for sone sort of cult revival like what has happened with vinyl
Last edited:
FunkMiller
Gold Member
And loses you billions. See: Marvel/Star Wars.
twilo99
Gold Member
It’s simply more expensive to expand rather than replace.
twilo99
Gold Member
The cinematic single player boxed sales in Spain type are the most passionate and vocal ones
The only reason I still want a PS5 is to play ps4 games with a silent console. The ps4 pro I have is just to loud to enjoy playing on it.
Killjoy-NL
Member
But nothing is being replaced.
The Gaas strategy is to add more diversity to the Playstation library, rather than releasing singleplayer after singleplayer game.
SkylineRKR
Member
The problem is Sony has just released Spiderman 2 last fall. And they already released a new Horizon (+DLC), God of War, Ratchet and GT game this gen. Which means sequels to those won't come any time soon, but perhaps late 2025 or somewhere in 2026. Returnal is also 3 years old by now, and this year might be the time to announce a sequel or new game.
The issues here are the no shows of Naughty Dog, which is still absent on PS5 as Sony's flagship studio. And maybe Sucker Punch, though GoT came out really late into the PS4 life (mere months before the PS5 itself in fact). These studios likely won't make GaaS games, ND even shut down their Factions project.
But looking past the awful State of Play, this year saw PS5 getting Rise of the Ronin, Granblue Fantasy, Stellar Blade, FFVII Rebirth already. And these are just the exclusives. I am sure more core games will be announced in due time and eventually ND, Sucker Punch, Bluepoint and Housemarque will announce something. Studios like Firesprite and Bungie (since Destiny) were never on this board, as long as Sony's main studios don't dabble with this GaaS shit I see not much of an issue yet.
I am all for lowering budgets for games, and favor gameplay instead of details and chasing realism, essentially cutting down dev time and costs. My problem with the industry in general is the long dev cycles, and the forced pandering by shits like Sweet Baby.
The issues here are the no shows of Naughty Dog, which is still absent on PS5 as Sony's flagship studio. And maybe Sucker Punch, though GoT came out really late into the PS4 life (mere months before the PS5 itself in fact). These studios likely won't make GaaS games, ND even shut down their Factions project.
But looking past the awful State of Play, this year saw PS5 getting Rise of the Ronin, Granblue Fantasy, Stellar Blade, FFVII Rebirth already. And these are just the exclusives. I am sure more core games will be announced in due time and eventually ND, Sucker Punch, Bluepoint and Housemarque will announce something. Studios like Firesprite and Bungie (since Destiny) were never on this board, as long as Sony's main studios don't dabble with this GaaS shit I see not much of an issue yet.
I am all for lowering budgets for games, and favor gameplay instead of details and chasing realism, essentially cutting down dev time and costs. My problem with the industry in general is the long dev cycles, and the forced pandering by shits like Sweet Baby.
Loxus
Member
Opinions are great and all but there is a reason none of us are running a billion dollar company.
We talk about Sony is out of touch and gamers want single player games. But yet, it's the gamers who are playing and spending more and more on multi-player games.
Why don't we blame the gamers?
Cause looking at that chart is making these so called single player gamers look like hypocrites.
You know what else amazes me about this gamers don't want multi-player games?
All the top PS3 and PS4 single player games had multi-player.
The Last of Us,
Max Payne 3,
Uncharted 2, 3 & 4
Red Dead Redemption 1 & 2,
Grand Theft Auto 4 & 5,
Grand Turismo,
The list goes on and on.
Multi-player didn't stop these single player games from being successful or impacted their quality. In fact, multi-player added value to single player games. Some gamers even brought those games to play the multi-player only.
Another thing, Naughty Dog has been putting multi-player in a lot of their games for years, then gamers at all surprise that they were working on TLoU2 multi-player. I don't get it, are gamers suffering from alzheimer's or something?
We talk about Sony is out of touch and gamers want single player games. But yet, it's the gamers who are playing and spending more and more on multi-player games.
Why don't we blame the gamers?
Cause looking at that chart is making these so called single player gamers look like hypocrites.
You know what else amazes me about this gamers don't want multi-player games?
All the top PS3 and PS4 single player games had multi-player.
The Last of Us,
Max Payne 3,
Uncharted 2, 3 & 4
Red Dead Redemption 1 & 2,
Grand Theft Auto 4 & 5,
Grand Turismo,
The list goes on and on.
Multi-player didn't stop these single player games from being successful or impacted their quality. In fact, multi-player added value to single player games. Some gamers even brought those games to play the multi-player only.
Another thing, Naughty Dog has been putting multi-player in a lot of their games for years, then gamers at all surprise that they were working on TLoU2 multi-player. I don't get it, are gamers suffering from alzheimer's or something?
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
Sony can do whatever they need to do. I just know that it became incredibly obvious as early as 2021 that I dont want to focus on it. All the signs have been there for years now but people are really slow to acknowledge things sometimes. Just the complete lack of communication, destruction of E3 show culture, price raising with limited paid upgrade paths was enough for me to see some large red flags pretty early on. People love it though. Sony consumer brand loyalty is on par with Apple this gen.
Markio128
Gold Member
I think the sad fact of the matter is that us old-skool gamers are becoming a rare commodity in the grand scheme of things. We’re kind of like the old men shaking their fist at the clouds, trying to convince our kids that Pink Floyd are better than Taylor Swift (they are).
Of course Sony are going to try and appeal to the most recent gen - the ones who are effectively providing Sony with enough money to spend on the less frequent big-budget games.
Do I like it? Nope. But then, I don’t like the top 40 anymore either. In fact, I couldn’t tell you a single song from the top 40. I was all over that shit in the 80’s and 90’s.
It wouldn’t surprise me if more people bought the last GTA game for the multiplayer portion.
Of course Sony are going to try and appeal to the most recent gen - the ones who are effectively providing Sony with enough money to spend on the less frequent big-budget games.
Do I like it? Nope. But then, I don’t like the top 40 anymore either. In fact, I couldn’t tell you a single song from the top 40. I was all over that shit in the 80’s and 90’s.
It wouldn’t surprise me if more people bought the last GTA game for the multiplayer portion.
hemo memo
You can't die before your death
Because they were forcing multiplayer into everything and anything. See Bioshock 2 for example. Not BECAUSE of multiplayer.
Dr. Wilkinson
Gold Member
I was going to post something similar but you said it better than I could have.
I’d just add that we have yet to see more than like one first-party from scratch PS5-only single player games on the level of LoU or Ghost of Tsushima. Which I think is the primary issue.
veterangamerUK
Member
What are you smoking?
ShirAhava
Plays with kids toys, in the adult gaming world
This! PSN free online days were the best
MG4 Online and Uncharted 2 muti were some of the best times I had with my PS3
Along with Wipeout, Warhawk/Starhawk and Motorstorm
PS3 was a very balanced console
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Looking at how Concord took so much of the opening, it's clear the streams aren't for those older fans anymore. It's there to entice a newer, younger, crowd.
TheAmazingSpiderMan
Member
I feel like PS peaked during the ps4 era and it will only further get lacklustre going forward. Ps6 etc.. who really cares? It’ll be GaaS and probably get 1 title per studio and that’s it.
SkylineRKR
Member
He isn't wrong but with many of its top selling games it wasn't the main draw. Uncharted had MP from 2 onward and I doubt many players bought it for this mode alone. MP was usually some side activity. At some point even God of War and Tomb Raider came up with multiplayer modes.
However, PS3 had a good rate of output with games not being too bloated yet. Uncharted had an appropriate runtime and was fit for replays. So while there were games like Warhawk and MAG around, there was also an entire Uncharted trilogy (+TLOU and DLC), 2 Infamous games, a Motorstorm trilogy etc.
RickMasters
Member
You are not wrong. There comes a point when all these companies shift their focus to the younger audience. It’s just the nature of businesses that are entertainment focused.
Imtjnotu
Member
No tf it wasn't
Killjoy-NL
Member
Older folks need to accept that they are gradually being placed in a back seat.
Boss Mog
Member
That may be true, but the thing is Gen Z and Gen Alpha, don't really like home consoles, they're on their phones mostly, on social media, but if they do end up gaming on an other device it's most likely a Switch or a PC. The people that still actually buy PlayStation console games are Gen X and Millennials, they're also the people with the most purchasing power, so really if Sony wants money that's who they should continue to cater to and not to people who will mostly never care about their products.
ShadyAcshuns
Member
Came to that conclusion a while back. Not only gaming, but music and film as well. I couldn't even tell you who 90% of new musical artists are these days.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Represent.
Represent(ative) of bad opinions
Lmao, how can anyone on this forum disagree with this article?
Jesus - learn to criticize your fav console maker. Otherwise they will just keep doing the same thing.
So, all these hero shooters, the GAAS push, generic games like concord, endless remakes and remasters, hideous, last-gen looking games coming out of Japan.. that inspires you?
Sony used to bring the heat with every show. Stop.
Jesus - learn to criticize your fav console maker. Otherwise they will just keep doing the same thing.
So, all these hero shooters, the GAAS push, generic games like concord, endless remakes and remasters, hideous, last-gen looking games coming out of Japan.. that inspires you?
Sony used to bring the heat with every show. Stop.
Sushi_Combo
Member
Unfortunately they are trying to capture the next generation of young folks, which do not prioritize Single player games when they fire up their systems.
Men_in_Boxes
Snake Oil Salesman
Because it's clickbait designed to attract old man yells at cloud types.
thicc_girls_are_teh_best
Member
Bruh you did not just give Ninja Theory a W here when then only accomplished those graphics by making a LITERAL 5-hour walking simulator tech demo.
Because that's basically what Hellblade 2 is. And I say that as someone who had a lot of faith in the game to, well, be more of a game and improve upon the first. Somehow it's worst than the first in combat, puzzles and story. How do you regress that much with a sequel?
The good news is, Astro Bot could be the start of Sony bringing that type of stuff back to the ecosystem WRT 1P-developed efforts. Yes games like it won't do Spiderman 2 numbers, but they don't need to. More importantly, they shouldn't be expected to in order to justify their existence.
Like it's been said, these type of games add variety to the offerings and even if they collectively (either with other games of their ilk, or with bigger games taken into consideration) only stimulate say an extra million console sales over a generation, that's still 1 million systems that may not have been sold otherwise.
Last edited:
Represent.
Represent(ative) of bad opinions
No it isn't clickbait, everything in it was true. They have brushed single player AAA experiences to the side in favor of GAAS trash. Its pretty obvious. Finally an article calls it out instead of pussyfooting their way around the bush