• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Report: Disney seizing more control over Marvel Studios. Scrapping/re-writing script

Status
Not open for further replies.

mreddie

Member
Uhm, what? Growing up I knew who Spider Man, Batman, Superman and the Green Lantern were. I vaguely knew who Captain America was. I had never heard of Iron Man or Thor and I absolutely know I'm not alone in that

Unless you played the games or saw the 90s caroons, you wouldn't know half the heroes. I didn't know about the JLA til the cartoon came out.
 
Uhm, what? Growing up I knew who Spider Man, Batman, Superman and the Green Lantern were. I vaguely knew who Captain America was. I had never heard of Iron Man or Thor and I absolutely know I'm not alone in that
I could recognize Thor because of the silly hat and IronMan was aired with the X-men cartoon, heck we even got this sweet baby.
1170170796-00.jpg
 

mreddie

Member
This is dumb. Studios make $200 milion successes/bombs all the time that aren't related to superheroes.

2008: "Making a live action movie about Alice in Wonderland? That sounds lame."
2009: "Making a movie about RED? That sounds lame."
2013: "Making a live action movies about Sleeping Beauty and Cinderella That sounds lame."
 

enzo_gt

tagged by Blackace
This reads like a tabloid magazine.

Aren't people getting a little ahead of themselves here?
I think the article was explicitly made to catch people trying to hide their desire for the downfall of Marvel Studios slipping with how far people are stretching things off of what is as valid as other concocted BS comic book film rumours. We caught a few in this thread.
 

ReiGun

Member
Yeah, it baffles me too. "Thor and Iron Man 3 are terrible lol" Compared to WHAT exactly? I mean, different opinions and all but I think some people just have some really bizarre standards.

Compared to other movies that person has seen that were more in line with their tastes. Or perhaps, they are judging the films on their own merits rather than comparing them to something else and don't find them that enjoyable.

There's nothing "bizarre" about people having different taste.
 
This doesn't make a ton of sense to me, why does them being good/bad have to be dependent on other movies?

It's a bit of a confusing rhetorical rant (sounded better in my head). I was sort of playing off the other post in that if those movies are considered bad/terrible to some people what does that make movies like Green Lantern or the Last Stand, movies that are widely considered terrible?
 

anaron

Member
I think the article was explicitly made to catch people trying to hide their desire for the downfall of Marvel Studios slipping with how far people are stretching things off of what is as valid as other concocted BS comic book film rumours. We caught a few in this thread.
Yes, the anti-marvel conspiracy.

Lol
 
This is hilarious. Not that I don't think executives wouldn't meddle, because that's kind of what they do but now Disney is the big bad in all of this. Marvel is now under danger of churning out 'homogenized and flat' movies. I don't know what movies these blind ass people been seeing, but that's kind of the status quo with these kind of movies. Marvel has made eight movies before Winter Soldier, and they only managed to make two of them of any real quality whereas the rest were basically flat or forgettable. Disney is going to make a real blow to the integrity of these kind of movies, I'm sure.


pretty much.
 
They announced 1 FILM PER YEAR, from now until end of time. Of course it will get worse, they will exploit every single popular character they can.

I prefer that actually, because some of them will inevitably be bad and some of them will inevitably be good. So why not let more directors and writers take a stab at what is one of the richest universes in fiction. And the mythology has already been defiled heavily so it's not like there's a perfect streak to preserve.
 
I'm sorry, but Latino Review do not 'largely hit'. When it comes to their scoops/exclusives/insider information, their batting average is maybe 1 in 6.
 

Instro

Member
I prefer that actually, because some of them will inevitably be bad and some of them will inevitably be good. So why not let more directors and writers take a stab at what is one of the most rich universe in fiction.

Well I wouldn't say its the most rich, but it certainly has incredible potential and its the only major franchise in the space opera type genre.
 
Wait... theres a Ms. Marvel script! #heavybreathing why did no one tell me!?
-blacksout-

either way hope it works out for Marvel and Antman. Disney or whoever is pressuring the creativity of the movies needs to back off, hopefully they do because the ire of fans is harsh and I think they will soon find that out.
 

Sub_Level

wants to fuck an Asian grill.
This is hilarious. Not that I don't think executives wouldn't meddle, because that's kind of what they do but now Disney is the big bad in all of this. Marvel is now under danger of churning out 'homogenized and flat' movies. I don't know what movies these blind ass people been seeing, but that's kind of the status quo with these kind of movies. Marvel has made eight movies before Winter Soldier, and they only managed to make two of them of any real quality whereas the rest were basically flat or forgettable. Disney is going to make a real blow to the integrity of these kind of movies, I'm sure.

I like the MCU movies, they're fun, but I can agree with you.
 

Instro

Member
I'm sorry, but Latino Review do not 'largely hit'. When it comes to their scoops/exclusives/insider information, their batting average is maybe 1 in 6.

Yeah I don't think most people see their "rumors" for most things, its terrible. This reads like some info that's been creatively interpreted.
 

Tobor

Member
This reads like a tabloid magazine.

Aren't people getting a little ahead of themselves here?

Of course it reads like a tabloid. Movie gossip sites are tabloids.

They're using the Wright departure to spin a click bait narrative. Not surprising.
 

DMczaf

Member
I'm sorry, but Latino Review do not 'largely hit'. When it comes to their scoops/exclusives/insider information, their batting average is maybe 1 in 6.

They still bring up the Heath Ledger scoop when people question their cred or when they want to brag about their cred. That shit was 8 years ago.

It was a good get, but 8 years is 8 years.
 

IceCold

Member
Can someone explain the thought process of Hollywood execs? Maybe I'm stupid but if I was one of them I'd let marvel do their thing. They seem to know what their doing.
 
DoFP is a good X Men movie, almost the best. (X2 to me, still the best one.) but over Winter Soldier? Nope.

Better than Thor 2, ASM2 and Wolverine? Maybe.

Also

2006: "Making a movie about Iron Man? Who's he? He sounds lame."
2009: "Making a movie about Thor? Who's he? He sounds lame."
2012: "Making a movie about Guardians of the Galaxy? Who're they? They sound lame."
2014: "Making a movie about Antman? Who's he? He sounds lame."

Every fucking time...


Antman solo movie is about as interesting as fantastic four or plastic man getting a solo movie. I give most super hero movies a chance though.
 
Who? What is his reputation?

A blogger with a lot of friends in high places. If he says it is legit then it is legit at the time he twtt'd it.

Also, Devin may be a giant asshole but the guy never prints anything he hasn't checked up on. If he says Joss is looking to leave he probably heard that from someone at Disney or Joss himself.

Can someone explain the thought process of Hollywood execs? Maybe I'm stupid but if I was one of them I'd let marvel do their thing. They seem to know what their doing.


Marvel is apart of Hollywood. If everything Devin says is true they're doing it to themselves.
 

Gartooth

Member
Something odd is that the Latino Review report mentions Marvel execs being the ones to mess up Ant-Man, but that Badass Digest story is pinning the blame on Disney execs right?
 

Fuchsdh

Member
Total speculation, but Disney probably doesn't want any tonal drift in its Marvel franchisees. So if Wright's Ant Man was more an offbeat slapstick comedy heist film than a gritty action movie, it might not fit into the MCU big picture. That homogeny would make the Avengers movies stronger, but ensure the individual franchises can't ever be that interesting in their adaptations.

That really doesn't describe any of the mainline Marvel universe films as of late, even The Winter Soldier.
 

zeron

Banned
they did it to pixar, why would marvel be any different ( they both bring in alot of money, plus pixar movies are usually critically acclaimed).

Pixar now make trash like cars and are forced to do sequels to franchices like toy story or else it would go to another studio.
 

Cheebo

Banned
People can claim it is nonsense from Latino Review but when Faraci and Film Critic Hulk both back it up how are people still trying to deny this?
 

Pikawil

Unconfirmed Member
they did it to pixar, why would marvel be any different ( they both bring in alot of money, plus pixar movies are usually critically acclaimed).

Pixar now make trash like cars and planes, and are forced to do sequels to franchices like toy story or else it would go to another studio.
As much as we can agree that Pixar has gone to the dumps after Toy Story 3, I feel the urge to correct you:

Planes isn't Pixar, it's DisneyToon Studios.
 
Something odd is that the Latino Review report mentions Marvel execs being the ones to mess up Ant-Man, but that Badass Digest story is pinning the blame on Disney execs right?

It sounds like Kevin Feige supported Edgar Wright and was overruled.

Latino-Review:
Edgar & Joe were upset by the sudden, out of nowhere lack of faith in them as filmmakers. Fiege had always batted for them but this felt like it came from the higher ups.
 

Pikawil

Unconfirmed Member
2010, how long did Disney own Pixar at that point?
Four years, the Disney-Pixar merger being complete on 2006. Which is incidentally close enough to the story at hand in this topic, 2014 being Marvel's fifth Disney year (well, it'll be in about three months).

Hmmm, the Disney era of Power Rangers also started to go to the dogs on their fourth season... let's see if 2016-2017 marks the beginning of the Disney doom of Star Wars with that pattern.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom