Support NeoGAF

[firehawk12]

Once again, you're talking about a studio that doesn't do character animation well, let alone anything else.

Anyway, when did you start paying attention to the actual animation?

More human kinaesthetics than animation I suppose? That and I've been a fan of watching people pretend to be soldiers for the last two decades (Act of Valor, movie of the year

Spoiler

lol

), so it's weird when something doesn't really match up to what you've seen.

I suppose if you're a sports guy and have watched sports all your life, you'd find the movements in say, Kuroko's Basketball or Knight in the Area, not matching real life movements.

Why do you hate Ao? Is it because he's bland?

Well, his blandness inspires indifference more that hate. They seem to be building up to a reunion of some kind, and that seems to be the way to draw out this "nothing" of a show.

 

[BluWacky]

On the other hand, when we consider that this is a BONES production, when was the last time that an original BONES anime layered all these elements together and managed to resolve everything successfully at the end?

When was the last time that ANY anime did this, given the propensity of the industry to produce ridiculous non-endings and the overall unambitious nature of most anime storylines?

 

[wonzo]

Koikelupin 11

So basically,

Spoiler

Oscar killed himself by jumping into the river with the bomb he planted under the bridge while not only posing as Fujiko Mine, but also doing the bidding of the owls all because he wanted to get into Zenigata's pants.

That's pretty dumb.

Spoiler

Why didn't he just throw the bomb into the river? I mean, I can kinda understand it from a the-jig-is-up/redemption standpoint but it just seems like a rather lazy way to end things.

 

[Risette]

Realistic gunning in this video. Innocence spoils. Best part.

I guess it helps that Oshii is a bit of a gun nut. All of his movies with guns have fairly good depictions of guns.

 

[cajunator]

Out of nowhere: Discotek Announces DVD Release of Mad Bull 34 Series

OH DAMN. I am so buying that!

 

[PdotMichael]

Just makes it more noteworthy as extra attention to detail when it's done right though.

although I'm still the opinion that the animations in the last Jormungand episode were accurate. And I have some first hand experiences.

 

[firehawk12]

Realistic gunning in this video. Innocence spoils. Best part.

I guess it helps that Oshii is a bit of a gun nut. All of his movies with guns have fairly good depictions of guns.

Look at all those guns.

 

[Risette]

Look at all those guns.

And a few swords!

 

[/XX/]

Realistic gunning in this video. Innocence spoils. Best part.

I guess it helps that Oshii is a bit of a gun nut. All of his movies with guns have fairly good depictions of guns.

I think you should have brought back your good analysis on that scene, pizzaroll! I'll do it for you (http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=35259756&postcount=3231).

One example of that attention to detail; I've seen comments stating the extremely realistic representation of Togusa's MA.TE.BA semi-automatic revolver on this, down to the recoil kick compared to other revolvers (and handguns) of similar caliber shown.

 

[Defuser]

Tis good to be playing dragon's dogma.

Edit: boo, level 25 and a bunch of useless skills. But I hired them nonetheless.

 

[wonzo]

Jormungand 10 aka CLIMES AGAINST HUMANITY

The gun battles in this show really are complete and shite when compared to dat Innocence sakuga posted above. Fortunately, the pacing in this show made sure that this arc didn't overstay its welcome.

 

[Risette]

I think you should have brought back your good analysis on that scene, pizzaroll! I'll do it for you (http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=35259756&postcount=3231).

One example of that attention to detail; I've seen comments stating the extremely realistic representation on this of Togusa's MA.TE.BA semi-automatic revolver, down to the recoil kick compared to other revolvers (and handguns) of similar caliber shown.

I forgot which thread I posted it in. Thanks!

I should revisit that scene with the new knowledge I've acquired over the months, especially in regards to editing and cuts. I learn quickly it seems.

 

[Train of Midnight]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

 

[PdotMichael]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

bad CG mecha fights and bad character design.

 

[Dedication Through Light]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

PV doesnt really look that interesting.

 

[Envelope]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

It's an adaption of a spinoff novel of a spinoff eroge of another eroge. Don't expect much.

 

[Risette]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

Garbage.

 

[cajunator]

The rest of my Madoka set will arrive today.
The collector in me is excited and the animu watcher in me is gonna marathon that son of a bitch all night long. I'm really curious to see what changes Shaft made once they had actual money to work with.

 

[Basileus777]

So... this Muv Luv... What are we expecting, here?

As good as Muv Luv Alternative is, this just looks like a low budget training school moe show.

 

[Envelope]

The rest of my Madoka set will arrive today.
The collector in me is excited and the animu watcher in me is gonna marathon that son of a bitch all night long. I'm really curious to see what changes Shaft made once they had actual money to work with.

You seem to be under the misapprehension that the style SHAFT shows employ is due to budget issues.

 

[Risette]

You seem to be under the misapprehension that the style SHAFT shows employ is due to budget issues.

Yeah, it's talent issues.

And schedule issues I guess.

 

[Train of Midnight]

*sigh* I was hoping for a replacement for Infinite Stratos...

My journey continues.

PV doesnt really look that interesting.

Holy moley that looks bad. I might check out the first ep or two, because why the fuck not.

 

[wonzo]

*sigh* I was hoping for a replacement for Infinite Stratos...

My journey continues.

bad CG mecha fights and bad character design.

i dunno, that sounds about right to me

 

[Envelope]

i dunno, that sounds about right to me

You mean you don't like the amazing character design from IS?!

 

[cajunator]

You seem to be under the misapprehension that the style SHAFT shows employ is due to budget issues.

It is well known that Shaft makes some heavy revisions to things in disc releases from the TV broadcast.

 

[Envelope]

It is well known that Shaft makes some heavy revisions to things in disc releases from the TV broadcast.

that's not usually due to the budget. (the exception being Bakemonogatari, and even then it's limited to like 1 episode.)

Or at least not the monetary budget, I guess you could make an argument about how they schedule their time.

 

[Risette]

A new meaning to time is money.

And it works too, I guess.

 

[Ryuukan]

Lupin 11:

I thought this show already had a train wreck. Looks like it's heading for another.

 

[PdotMichael]

Yeah, it's talent issues.

How is this a talent issue if they make the best shows?

(with some of the best animations scenes in the industry)

 

[Risette]

How is this a talent issue if they make the best shows?

best bad shows

(with some of the best animations scenes in the industry)

This is objectively wrong.

 

[Narag]

You mean you don't like the amazing character design from IS?!

I could only tolerate her in one brief scene where someone asks someone else if they've met her while she's standing in the foreground. The smile that appeared fit her so well.

 

[wonzo]

You mean you don't like the amazing character design from IS?!

i cant say that i've gotten up to her yet but

 

[Envelope]

i cant say that i've gotten up to her yet but

You should stop now then, before you do reach her.

 

[Theonik]

If only we could find a way to mix them both.

Well we have Girl und Pantser coming soon.

http://i.imgur.com/PWbFs.jpg

Now see, if AnimeGAF had reviewed this show those pro and con points would have been reversed.

 

[wonzo]

You should stop now then, before you do reach her.

saying this just makes me even hungrier

 

[madp]

You mean you don't like the amazing character design from IS?!

There's something deeply evil about this that I can't seem to put into words.

 

[Dedication Through Light]

Sket Dance 62

Some funny moments throughout, definitely went in the opposite direction I was thinking with the second skit medicine.

 

[Envelope]

Star Driver 2


Some more great mecha action in this episode as well, Bones has a very talented team. Unfortunately, the great artstyle and animation is marred by the weak characterization and setting.

I hinted at it in my impressions about the first episode, but the discrepancy between the high-school daily life and the sexually tinted bizarre "conquer the world!" plot is very jarring. To start with, many of the characters at Southern Cross High (the school where Takuto, the main character, is currently residing) lead double lives.

High School wife by day...

Cult leading, mecha driving, power seeking dominatrix by night

Of course, this is an extremely common occurance in every form of media, and that alone wouldn't mean much to the quality of a character. However, let's examine the case of one single character from the show, the green-haired girl featured above.

The first time Takuto takes notice of her, presumably due to her odd, attention grabbing line. What does she mean by it? Our curiosity is (hopefully) ignited.

...and now we find out. Our first impression is of a flirty, somewhat sensual girl. I guess this is a bit of my own opinion, but the impression left makes the kiss seem more sexy and sensual.

Takuto acts as a stand in for the audience in this scene. After something so strange happened, he wants to rationalize it in the simplest way possible.

And the least likely reply is given. One thing to note here is that, with an invitation as obscure as "You don't mind the glass, do you?", the boy knew exactly what she wanted. Either kissing through glass is a big thing at this school, or both of them are in some "insider's circle" type thing. The other, of course, is that this girl kisses strangers as if it was the most natural thing in the world. None of the other classmates even react, despite the fact that the ostensibly more shy, more innocent Wako is present. Only the outsider, Takuto, is surprised. This provides a bit more evidence for the "common occurance" theory, I guess.

However, another character does take issue with it. I'll tie another scene that happens later back into this, but for now, we know that at least one other person does in fact not approve of it.

And she fires a quick retort back. There's hints that there's a rivalry between the class pres and the green-haired girl, and these hints find solid ground later on. (more on that later).

There's a lot of importance placed on the fact it was through the glass, and besides the obvious, it does gain more meaning later.

And finally, she does a "proper" introduction, after we the viewer, and Takuto in the show, have already determined quite a bit about her character. It might be just me, but now that's she's turned her attention onto Takuto, I'd expect a bit of explanation on what occurred.

However, she immediately treats Takuto as another target. So far, though she is rather seductive for the average high school student, there's nothing too far out of the realm of possibility here.

..but it's all thrown out the window the next moment. Not only does she happily initiate kisses with complete strangers but she's already married, and at face value a monogamous relationship is not important to her. She could be lying about the marriage, but with a ring, and no obvious reason for such a lie, it doesn't seem likely. So now we have a strong impression of this character, but also a lot of mystery behind her.

As hopefully you can see, it's a really bizarre introduction. That alone, of course, isn't a bad thing, and indeed, I think her introduction, taken by itself, was a pretty good scene, and she might be an interesting character. However, the big flaw with this scene, and the big flaw with this show in general, is the disproportionate reaction. Quite simply, no one but Takuto bats an eyelid. The easiest explanation for this is that everyone else is simply used to it, but that seems unlikely in the light of several other elements. Firstly, as I already mentioned, there's Wako. She seems to be very much the type of character that would be offended by her behavior, and it's very surprising that she shows absolutely no reaction at all, and indeed isn't even shown in that scene at all. Of course, that doesn't discount the potential that everyone is just used to it, but it does strike me as odd. Then there's Takuto's reaction. Though he does show a significant amount of surprise and uneasiness, it's completely forgotten the moment the scene finishes. I understand that everything I've described so far might not convince anyone, but it's really just the tip of the Iceburg, and there's a lot more to come.

Random :Cajun moment for filler.

In the scene directly following the previous one (that sounds a bit redundant...), Takuto meets the drama club. It's an expository scene, and quite a bit of information is revealed, but it's done in an awkward fashion that again tells of a discrepancy between what we see happening and what the characters do.

(In case it's unclear, Cybodies are what the mechs are called in Star Driver.)

Takuto is already famous! But, hold up a second. How does she know about Cybodies? Nothing in the show so far had led me to believe that anyone other than the secret organization knew about the existence of them. Again, it could quite easily be common knowledge, but the way it's just dropped in is very jarring. However, there's more wrong with the scene than something as innocuous as that.

This is a really important fact. Time stops for everyone, except those who are actually in the "arena" where the mechs fight. So, how does she know that Takuto fought? Unless she herself is a part of the secret group (called Kiraboshi, apparently), she should have no idea when a fight takes place!

At this point, we have to assume that she is in on the whole plot. Not only does she know of the existence of the fight, and the participants, but she also knows of the reason why the fight occured. Unfortunately, no one in the show draws the same conclusions.

Since he's the main character of a shounen show, it's to be expected that Takuto suffers from a general dumbness, but it still makes for a strange scene. Takuto immediately regards the drama club as an authority on bullet time mecha fights, and asks just who his opponents are.

Immediately, he's given an explanation. If someone could take a Cyborg out of the time warp, and use it in normal time, they would be unstoppable. Sadly, it doesn't make sense. Wouldn't being able to move through time be a huge advantage to anyone trying to take over the world? Some world leader does something you don't like, wants to start a war... bam! stop time, take him out, avert a crisis!

And also, here's really where the dissonance between what's happening and what the characters react flairs up. So, high school students have control over time-stopping killing machines, it's well known enough that people in the drama club know, these students want to take over the world, that's also well known... Where are the teachers? The investigation? The police? The government? Quite simply, why does no one care? Characters like Wako, who is put in mortal danger every time a fight takes place, should care, right? But she doesn't... or at least not as much as she should.

Wako, if you're in constant danger of being kidnapped, mind-probed, enslaved, or killed, you should be doing a lot more than just transferring schools. And what's worse, is many of her friends know! But the reaction is hugely disproportionate!

To end the scene, Takuto seemingly finally realizes that something is off with this drama club.

However, his body language and facial expression reveals it's not a big deal to him. Again, there's just too much dissonance going on.

Hopefully by this point you can at least understand what I mean when I say there's a large discrepancy between what you see and what the characters do. However, it not only applies to the plot/setting, it applies to the characters too. Remember miss high school wife? Let's take another look.

Here we see her in her role in Kiraboshi, the group who wants to bring revolution to the world. Her dominatrix get up does fit with what we know of her personality, but it still reeks of pointless fanservice. If you're going to be piloting a mecha, surely an outfit more akin to the plugsuits of Evangelion make more sense than skin tight leather? Remember miss class pres, who was the only student who had a problem with Kanoko?

...here she is (I think, the lack of brightly coloured hair makes it difficult to determine. Either way, it won't really lessen the point I'm making).

...another ridiculous outfit. The real problem isn't so much the outfit itself, but the bizarre juxtaposition between it and a meeting of people desiring to be world rulers, which reflects the overarching flaw this show has. It's actually quite similar to Lagrange in that way. Lagrange was far worse, and didn't even have fabulous mechs and magical boy transformations to make up for it, but I might eventually drop Star Driver if it continues down this path. If it is indeed the class pres, it makes the reason for their animosity more apparent. There's currently a power struggle going on with the higher members of Kiraboshi, and so there's no real friendship to be found between any of the members.

If i'm doing a decent job at this, you should have a definite grasp of what I mean. Of course, Star Driver is by no means alone in doing this (I already cited Lagrange as another example), but that hardly makes it any better. High-school anime are particularly prone to this, for obvious reasons. The mecha portions of Star Driver are quite fantastical, and if the high school had also been more fantastical there might have been less dissonance going on. I'll provide one last example, that also sheds some light on another peculiarity I already brought up.

Here's one of the managers of the school dorms. She sneaks into baths were her students (wards?), is a bit clumsy, as evidenced in the first episode, and, curiously, also has a certain fixation.

What's so significant about this glass kissing thing? Firstly, we should note that she is also quite familiar with this phenomenon, even though she wasn't present when Kanako did it earlier. Clearly, it really is something common at this school, or with a certain group. I'm hesitant to say which it is, since random people like the boy knew about it, even though he wasn't (or at least, hasn't shown up as of yet) a member of Kiraboshi.

Yes, Pink Hair is also a member of Kiraboshi, and I should hardly even need to mention what her outfit is like, but since I feel I should reward you for reading this far, here you go.

I feel like I've expounded enough on how silly it is with the whole double life thing going on, so I'll dispense with that for now.

Back to the kissing!

Finally, a kiss without the glass. One thing to note here: the boy shows no hesitation or unwillingness.

(Pink Hair is Scarlet Kiss)

Alright, now we're finally getting somewhere! Firstly, this casts a whole new light on Green Hair. Or at least it brings up an interesting possibility. Perhaps her own kiss has some sort of special power? At the same time, it brings up something strange. The boy (who piloted the mecha for this episode's fight) didn't care that he was being put under Scarlet Kiss's power. Perhaps he simply didn't know? Well, apart from the fact that Star Driver seems to prefer the approach of "Everyone but the MC knows everything going on", Kiraboshi themselves know of Scarlet Kiss's power. (The line was delivered by on of the leaders of Kiraboshi, not a monologue from Scarlet Kiss.). So why the hell did he do it? I'm not really expecting an answer from Star Driver, since it appears the show doesn't do things that way, but hopefully it is brought up again, even if it as simple as he has an undying love for her so he'll do whatever she wants anyway (in which case, why the kiss?).

Of course, if only a few people were in Kiraboshi, and if only a few people knew what was going on behind the scenes at this school, it wouldn't be so bad. Unfortunately, neither is the case. There's a huge crowd at Kiraboshi's meeting, and you can see a lot of random grunts in the background during the mecha fight.

Star Driver has a fair amount of interesting ideas, a nice artstyle, great animation, but unfortunately it has it's flaws as well. Perhaps it's too soon to be drawing all these conclusions when I've only finished 2 episodes, but a really good show would have avoided these problems in the first place.

 

[duckroll]

I already warned you guys about summarizing an entire episode with 20+ HD screens. Don't do that. It's not welcome on this forum.

 

[Envelope]

I already warned you guys about summarizing an entire episode with 20+ HD screens. Don't do that. It's not welcome on this forum.

K, I'll make them 480p next time.

 

[duckroll]

K, I'll make them 480p next time.

No, you will use 5 images or less the next time. You're on probation, just like ABF.

 

[chickdigger802]

So much scrolling...

uh...

Polar Bear Cafe 11

first part was fun. 2nd part was 'heartwarming'. Nothing that really stood out this eps though.

 

[duckroll]

Hey guys, if you want to make a post about a 20 minute episode with 20-30 HD images, I have just the thing for you: http://wordpress.com/

 

[tiff]

a good place to put all episode reviews really

 

[Train of Midnight]

But I really liked his summary :c

Spoiler

Please don't ban me

 

[Steroyd]

But I really liked his summary :c

That's not a summary, that's a whole episode in pictures, or at least I don't see the need to watch the episode now.

Which might be a good thing.

 

[Envelope]

That's not a summary, that's a whole episode in pictures, or at least I don't see the need to watch the episode now.

Which might be a good thing.

But I only posted about 3 minutes worth of scenes.

 

[PdotMichael]

But I only posted about 3 minutes worth of scenes.

your nick and the title of the anime are enough

 

[R_thanatos]

Medaka Box 11
This episode reminds me that Kumagawa is still the most hyped up villain over the longest period of time in the series. I mean once we found out how ridiculously broken

Spoiler

Najimu

was, she had already been around for a bit, so that kind of disqualifies her.

Anyway, good adaptation of a not bad fight. Couple of instances of good animation, mostly high tension, good use of music; I'd say they successfully transferred the first post-genre shift arc to animated form.

Now to wait for the bullshit original ending next week and see if there's any news of a 2nd season.

It's horrible that they end it like this

No naruto shippuden today?

Medaka Box 11

The anime has so much potential but fails to capitalize it. Words can not truly express how much I dislike Medaka. What was she even fighting for, why, why in the world did they power her up so much, utterly ridiculous. She has absolutely nothing going for her at all, no redeeming qualities, or even motivations, even worst she isnt even driven by friendship. Why do shonen series have to resort to giving attention to these terrible characters, first last weeks episode of Saint Seiya Omega with Yuna, and now today with Medaka in Medaka Box.

Can Zenkichi get in on the action? Unzen was/is way more appealing than Medaka and even had the better premise. For all purposes, I had to agree with Zenkichi about him, except for the part of liking Medaka more. I can already foresee that he will be extensively out of the plot, ugh.

Also the episodes featured illustration wasnt that good, like a bunch of scribbles.

You'll realise reading the manga that while she is in the league of the most broken characters, she is far from being the most broken ..And she do have motivations but that's explained later... as for the rest of your complain that's exactly why "Flask plan" and "the minus arc" must be animated...
This whole season was simply just a prologue to the good things

 

[chickdigger802]

Medaka box 11

This show is kinda dumb, with potential of growing into something cool.

Too bad it ends next week.

Dumb it is.