The real answer, as unsatisfying as it is, is that we don't know. It could be that a large number of primary voters will start paying attention and pivot towards an establishment figure. Or it could be that Trump is legitimately dominating the attention of the Republican base.
Nate Silver is right about much of what he is saying, historically, but his claim that Trump has no real chance is misguided.
This is a great post. This is exactly what is happening.
Here's what's going on right now.
1. Trump's voters are not going to abandon Trump because of what he says/does
2. We don't know if Trump's supporters are reliable voters
3. We do know response rates this early for primaries are shit, generally
4. We don't know if there are a lot of primary voters to come and no idea how they'll vote
5. This election has the potential to be crazy.
6. We don't know how many candidates will be around in January.
Honestly, it's kind of impossible to know what's truly going on. Primaries aren't this noticed this far out as this cycle with the GOP thanks to the Trump Clown Show. I know people who watched the GOP debates who never would have otherwise. Some of them are definitely not voting GOP, too.
I think Nate makes a very solid argument in his article. But I also agree he's waaaay too dismissive of him because this election has major WTF factor going on. Especially if we're witnessing the GOP national party's deconstruction.
Quite honestly, the only thing I'm sure of is that Trump's supporters are here to stay. But I have no idea how many non-Trump supporters are out there not really paying attention, yet.
So Snake is right. We just don't know what the hell is going on in the GOP race.
IPretty much this. With the added caveat that with every passing day Trump spends atop the polls it becomes harder and harder to see him lose. If he isn't done but January, I feel like he's got it all sown up. Which is scary as fuck..
This is also true, of course. With each passing day that Trump basically stays the course, the odds of him winning go up. Honestly, I don't see how anyone could not have it 50% Trump vs 50% field or better for the Donald. There's just nothing that makes you think Donald is an underdog, let alone a big one.
But I wouldn't go nuts and give up much more than 50%
right now. I think once Iowa settles, if it's something like Cruz #1 with Trump #2 and close and everyone else far, then we got a high chance of Trump. Of Course Trump winning Iowa makes it just about game over unless NH defects.