• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PoliGAF 2016 |OT15| Orange is the New Black

Status
Not open for further replies.
Saying it's all economic anxiety that drove this gives his voters an out, a way to say that no they are not racist or ok with racism. They should be forced to face what they are and created. Not to be given an easy out. They don't deserve it.

EDIT: Shit like this is why we keep losing. Because we refuse to twist the knife. I see that now.

P33loci.png
http://www.vox.com/2016/4/21/11451378/smug-american-liberalism
 

Boke1879

Member
Bernie is right tho.

Learn from your mistakes now, lest you want them to happen again. It seems like people want to sweep it under the rug.

Everyone in this thread has been talking about change being needed. Nothing is getting swept under the rug.

If you're Obama you're making calls and talking to people. Hell everyone is I'm sure trying to figure out how to move forward.
 
Even if this was a weird aberration because of Clintons liabilities, this electionew showed just how bad our organization is at the local level. We won't be able to take either section of Congress for a while and most of the state governments are gone.

And yes I would like to know why black blue collar voters don't have the economic anxiety disease that makes you vote for a racist.
 
I guess one thing we'll have to consider policy-wise is how to ease the transition into being a free-trade, more-open-borders country in a world that becomes increasingly smaller by the year.

I've been thinking quite a bit about this, and honestly, I don't think that you can have free trade without a robust social safety net.

It's going to get ugly for these Trump supporters over the next four years. One thing that's pretty amazing is that they've harmed us all with their vote, but they really fucked themselves because Paul Ryan is about to put them in a world of hurt. I probably get a tax cut out of this, actually, but these guys are fucked.

So what is smart policy to push to voters that can a) beef up a safety net for those who need to transition to other fields, and b) can be pitched in a way that the "hand-outs" attack isn't as effective pushback against it. The big issue is that these Trump voters will reject policies that they perceive as being beneficial to non-whites in any way, so how do we thread that needle in presenting such policies?
 

benjipwns

Banned
Cw1y_e_WQAAoUl_.jpg


"Economic Anxiety" though
Compare it to 2012/2008 though:
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/11/08/us/elections/exit-poll-analysis.html

Trump improved 20 points among those making $30,000 and under. He dropped almost 10 points among those making over $100,000 and $200,000.

Obama beat Romney 63-35 and McCain 65-33 and Kerry beat Bush 61-39 among those under $30,000. In the next category Obama beat Romney 57-42 and McCain 55-43.

Romney won those over $100,000 by 54-44.
http://elections.nytimes.com/2012/results/president/exit-polls
 
EDIT EDIT: I want to clarify that when I say I've come around I don't mean that I agree 100% with everything pigeon has said or is saying. I do mean that I've basically given up on the idea that there was some kernel of goodness in the Trump voter we should try to catch. My republican friends and family helped make it pretty obvious that some people made the choice to latch onto that kernel of goodness and follow where it lead them, while others threw it in the garbage so it wouldn't bother them anymore.

This is an excellent post, although in fairness remember that time you told me it was crazy to call Trump a fascist

I thought I argued against calling him a Nazi (a term I still would not support labeling him with). Even fascist is a bit technical for my taste too. But yeah, I've come around more or less. In my defense I didn't know that Trump has a magic ability to literally become worse with each consecutive day he exists.

EDIT:

I even posted a bit about this transition back in August actually.

I'll also add that after talking to my cousins I'm starting to become a little bit more sympathetic towards Pigeon's point of view (in the short term anyway). If even they (as Tea Party Rs) can't find anything defensible about the people who are supporting Trump, well, I dunno how else to interpret that besides a very bad look
 

Boke1879

Member
I know Trump pretty much put all the governing to Pence, but Trump is going to have to pull his weight as well. He's going to find out this job isn't just sitting around and giving speeches. He's going to have to do 4 years of constant travel and selling ideas. This man is going to look rough when it's all over.
 

Oblivion

Fetishing muscular manly men in skintight hosery
I mean, Bernie did say at the end that he's not going to help him with any of his racist, misogynistic shit...
 
Even if this was a weird aberration because of Clintons liabilities, this electionew showed just how bad our organization is at the local level. We won't be able to take either section of Congress for a while and most of the state governments are gone.

And yes I would like to know why black blue collar voters don't have the economic anxiety disease that makes you vote for a racist.

35% economic tariffs on China causing a recession and 20 million people losing their health insurance and everyone losing their food stamps will probably create a green tea party which will take control of most governor mansions and maybe the House in 2018.

We'll see.
 

pigeon

Banned

So I'm just going to come out and say this: I spent years arguing that we need to accept the rural white voter.

After 2004 I realized that America was a much more divided country than I thought it was, and I needed to try harder to understand the people who didn't live in California. I was surrounded by smug liberals who said that flyover states were full of stupid people.

I made these arguments! I said we needed to understand them and their desires! I advocated for dropping gun control for a long time. For this entire year I've been saying it's very important for the Democrats to rebuild rural white communities when they get into power, even though they are full of racists. I felt strongly that we needed to be more accepting and try to build community with the people of Ohio and Indiana and Nebraska.

I was wrong. This is 2016. I understand the rural white voter and their desires now. They want me to go away, and they voted for it. They do not want to live in peace.

I am not smug when I consider the life or opinions of a rural white voter. I am terrified. They are members of a proud old American tradition that allows people of color to be lynched for being uppity, then elects the lyncher to public office. They are the original sin of America.

You might have the privilege of saying that we need to stop condescending to them about how oppressing people of color is bad and learn to accept them.

I don't.
 
Any other NJ voters taking solace in the fact that more casinos were shut down by 77% of the voting population? At least that's something to feel good about. In addition my county was only 1,000 votes away from choosing Peter Jacob for Congress which would have been unthinkable a decade ago.
 
The other thing to keep in mind is that the sad fact is that the main reason Hillary didn't win was because of low turnout.

Despite what Trump may claim, very few people actually voted for him. He got less votes than McCain. He got less votes than Romney. And this is *with* an increased population! Democratic turnout was very low. People didn't listen to Obama. They booed. They didn't vote. And, I mean, you can blame a lot of that on Hillary as a flawed candidate. But in the end, it should show that Trump isn't some unstoppable machine. You just need a charismatic politician to go out there and motivate people to vote. Hopefully the Democrats can field a better candidate next time.

They may have won this time, but we're not out.

Trump will get more votes than both.

There are a lot of votes to be counted in the next week or two.
 
Everyone is losing their shit on that Bernie comment. WTF? Do you not want to work to improve our nation? Do you really want the Dems to be obstructionists-lite?

Dems need to be doing ground work right now. That doesn't mean not governing.
 
I'm sorry but some of this thread is a bit much, like Jesus Christ guys. Though I am a white, straight male so feel free to shit on me for saying that but I'm about to ditch this thread for good. Turn some of the doom and gloom into motivation on how to fix this mess.

There is a shitload of energy on the grassroots level for, what I might as well call, "not shitty Americans" and it is literally the day after the election. People are already trying to figure out how to fix this party (including in this thread!). On Twitter and Facebook I see tons of people more motivated than ever before to go out and make a difference and to fight back against hate at every level of government. I mean we are literally already seeing protests!
 
Trump made a lot of things lose meaning.
polls for one

well the national polls seem to be a moderate miss of about 3 points right now. Still (probably) called the popular vote winner. Looks like Clinton underperformed by about as much as Obama overperformed.

Electoral projections / some key state polling, however
 

Dierce

Member
I mean, Bernie did say at the end that he's not going to help him with any of his racist, misogynistic shit...

A single sentence denunciation after an entire paragraph of praise over what amounts to bullshit that will never happen in the first place.
 
You might have the privilege of saying that we need to stop condescending to them about how oppressing people of color is bad and learn to accept them.

I don't.

Yup. They hate us. I think white liberals can try to bridge that divide, but they want PoC dead and buried or at the very least stuffed into poor neighborhoods that they can drive through quickly with the windows rolled up.

I mean, it's fine if straight white liberals want to do this, but I don't think it's the role of PoC, or LGBTQ people for that matter, to do this. It's up to us to work together to vote in a bloc for the Democratic party and then agitate within the party for our goals while allowing the leadership to set up the courts, etc., to help get us what we need in order to be treated fairly.
 

jonjonaug

Member
Any other NJ voters taking solace in the fact that more casinos were shut down by 77% of the voting population? At least that's something to feel good about. In addition my county was only 1,000 votes away from choosing Peter Jacob for Congress which would have been unthinkable a decade ago.

I voted Yes because I work in the gambling industry and if Trump's policies cut off income from foreign markets there sure as hell better be an expanding domestic one.
 
I'm sorry but some of this thread is a bit much, like Jesus Christ guys. Though I am a white, straight male so feel free to shit on me for saying that but I'm about to ditch this thread for good. Turn some of the doom and gloom into motivation on how to fix this mess.

There is a shitload of energy on the grassroots level for, what I might as well call, "not shitty Americans" and it is literally the day after the election. People are already trying to figure out how to fix this party (including in this thread!). On Twitter and Facebook I see tons of people more motivated than ever before to go out and make a difference and to fight back against hate at every level of government. I mean we are literally already seeing protests!

Stop telling us how to feel about the most unqualified person ever be elected to the highest office in the land.
 

pigeon

Banned
You guys are really starting to lose it with your Anti-Bernie Echo Chamber. It's beyond ridiculous at this point.

Frankly, I have no particular bad feelings towards Bernie. I just don't want to hear more about him.

But a whole lot of people are really interested in telling me more about him today!
 

bplewis24

Neo Member
A single sentence denunciation after an entire paragraph of praise over what amounts to bullshit that will never happen in the first place.

I defy you to point out the "praise" of Trump in that statement. You can make a better case that Obama praised Trump in his speech today when he said he was "heartened" by his talk with him after talking about being on the "same team".
 

PBY

Banned
Frankly, I have no particular bad feelings towards Bernie. I just don't want to hear more about him.

But a whole lot of people are really interested in telling me more about him today!
It's a real question. The 1600 guys talked about it, as did the Slate gabfest crew. He was strongest where Hill was weakest, in some ways.
 

pigeon

Banned
It's a real question. The 1600 guys talked about it, as did the Slate gabfest crew. He was strongest where Hill was weakest, in some ways.

I definitely agree that Bernie was a less intersectional candidate and thus more palatable to white nationalists. I've been arguing that all year!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom