-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
AMERICAN HORROR STORY: Coven |OT| When witches don't fight, we burn....
- Thread starter Nemesis_
- Start date
- Status
indigo-cyclops
Member
HAHAHHA basically.
Her vision was fixed in the previous episode.
NipplesAndToes23
Member
I don't remember that happening. I could've sworn I watched the last episode too.
indigo-cyclops
Member
Maybe she'll show up. Delphine is nowhere to be found...But yea, there's no reason she should be dead considering she slit her throat early on.
This season just feels so sloppy and uncoordinated. There's a few great episodes, standalone, but as a logical season it makes little sense and is probably the worst of the three at this point. It's been a huge disappointment for me considering it had the best potential to be unique. Turns out, the often used insane asylum trope was the most interesting one.
Let's hope "Circus" is real, as they have another chance to do something bizarre, and hopefully IN FUCKING PERIOD again. If it isn't more visually interesting than Carnivale, then they failed.
NipplesAndToes23
Member
I didn't think anyone liked Asylum after your girl escaped from the serial killer and all the crazy shit that seemed like it was leading to nowhere.
It started off well, but then descended into the abyss with the convolution it added up. Crazy people, serial killers, aliens, nazi scientist, created monsters, aliens, the devil, and the angel of death? Surely just one of those things could've have been focused enough and could carry a theme for a season on its own.
It started off well, but then descended into the abyss with the convolution it added up. Crazy people, serial killers, aliens, nazi scientist, created monsters, aliens, the devil, and the angel of death? Surely just one of those things could've have been focused enough and could carry a theme for a season on its own.
Asylum was a mess and wasn't even fun half of the time. I thought it salvaged something in the final few episodes. But most of it was just blah.
I have liked this season MUCH more. It hasn't reached the heights of season one. And i wish dead meant dead. But, I enjoy the characters.
Queenie used one of Hank's guns which contained blessed silver bullets capable of countering magic.
NipplesAndToes23
Member
Yeah I do too, the resurrections don't bother me as much it's just how it's handled. There seems to be no repercussions for it with the swamp witch's case. I thought it was done nicely with Frankenboyfriend, but the three other people that were resurrected act just like they did when they were alive, when the pompous one came back they were made it seem like she was emotionless, but this episode she clearly was her normal self. I'd think once you died all your powers would be gone, but nope. The one person who loses theirs is alive.
Really? Damn I didn't know silver was good on werewolves, vamps, and witches too, that's one op element.
NipplesAndToes23
Member
I'm not saying it doesn't make sense, just that I don't like that it has no repercussion unlike Frankenboyfriend, zombies, and immortality.
Speaking of immortailty
.
Speaking of immortailty
You have to be an evil daughter of a dog to have your soul rejected by a spirit that claims the lives of infants
indigo-cyclops
Member
Yes, good catch. Totally missed that.
blackaroni
Member
Next weeks episode actually looks good. I really hate all of the young witches. The show would have been better without them. I still don't understand how they brought back that neighbor lady and just acted like nothing happened. Same with Kyle....oh he's fixed now. I hope this is the only episode that Stevie appears in.
blackaroni
Member
I have a feeling that she's gonna be back. No one dies.
Spectral Glider
Member
Papa Shango or whatever was cool, but that's about it. At this point, I don't care who the next supreme is as apparently they've all got super force powers but they're all easily killed and brought back, so what the fuck does it matter? Hopefully Papa Shango wipes all their dumb asses out.
Fantastical
Death Prophet
I thought tonight was really bad. I don't care anymore.
AlexMeloche
Member
Yeah, pretty shitty episode tonight.
was my favourite and I didn't felt a thing when
. (Not sure if I still need to hide it)
Nan
she was killed
bistromathics
facing a bright new dawn
Can't believe all the negativity in here. Hope none of you were posting "Community is back!!!!" last week.
Evil Nan is best Nan.
Evil Nan is best Nan.
"She's innocent. Mostly. She killed the neighbor but the bitch had it coming".
That's the only part of the episode I liked. I guess Marie & Fiona working together was amusing too. Oh and Myrtle, lmao. She's so weird, I love her.
What was the point of Joan and Luke again?
So Madison still thinks she's the next Supreme? Misty's not the stupid one...
Zoe was useless. Nan became annoying this episode but her "eat my shit" comment to Marie was gold.
I'm not sure I care about what happens to any of these people tbh. I was way more invested in Lana, Kitt and Sister Jude at this point last season.
That's the only part of the episode I liked. I guess Marie & Fiona working together was amusing too. Oh and Myrtle, lmao. She's so weird, I love her.
What was the point of Joan and Luke again?
So Madison still thinks she's the next Supreme? Misty's not the stupid one...
Zoe was useless. Nan became annoying this episode but her "eat my shit" comment to Marie was gold.
I'm not sure I care about what happens to any of these people tbh. I was way more invested in Lana, Kitt and Sister Jude at this point last season.
Matt_
World's #1 One Direction Fan: Everyone else in the room can see it, everyone else but you~~~
They have really ramped up everyones powers to 11 recently. I know there is a limited amount of episodes to work with and they need to keep people guessing about who the next supreme is, but it seems like everyone gains two new powers that they've never used every episode, making it very hard to keep track.
Kinda glad Nan has been killed off, she only had two sides to her and that was whining about the next door boy and whining because no one thought she was the next supreme. Part of me was expecting Fiona and Marie to turn on Papa though, try and take him down some how. Is he supposed to be some voodoo god?
Promo for 3x11
Kinda glad Nan has been killed off, she only had two sides to her and that was whining about the next door boy and whining because no one thought she was the next supreme. Part of me was expecting Fiona and Marie to turn on Papa though, try and take him down some how. Is he supposed to be some voodoo god?
Promo for 3x11
It's amazing how quickly Fiona went from doing everything to protect the Coven to wanting to kill all the other girls so she can stay alive. Not sure why Marie wanted to help her kill Nan either, not sure what she gets out of it.
You Know Nothing
Member
Not Madison being an Eminem fan.
Not too fussed about Nan's death. But the glimpse of sadistic Nan was pretty great.
Not too fussed about Nan's death. But the glimpse of sadistic Nan was pretty great.
Zoe
Member
Lance Reddick!
By killing Nan, Marie wouldn't have to give the baby to Papa Legba anymore and Fiona would have one suspect less in the running towards becoming America's Next Top Witch
Matt_
World's #1 One Direction Fan: Everyone else in the room can see it, everyone else but you~~~
Oh yeah of course she did, how did I forget that? I wonder if Marie will give the baby back or keep it as her own
Fenderputty
Banned
I was wondering why she resorted to drowning her. You're the fucking supreme.
And what's with that spell? They can make the FBI appear on any corporations doorstep?
Zoe
Member
Thanks!
I forgot Misty may have died
She's not dead, the two deaths were obvious.
pokeystaples
Banned
Myrtle stole this episode for me. When the camera panned out to her playing the theremin? "Don't be a hater dear."
Please gawd tell me Madison will not be the new Supreme.
Velcro Fly
Member
The new supreme is going to be
. I feel like it's almost been obvious with how they've handled it on the show.
___Zoe___
She's the only one one of them that really isn't completely insane
D
Deleted member 20920
Unconfirmed Member
It's obviously the
new stolen baby who is the supreme
I won't be surprised if it turns out to be Cordelia. Or no one at all.
Come on be a good sport and sympathize with all the shit she has to do to keeping the coven together. Being a supreme isn't easy.
Spectral Glider
Member
Yeah, that stuff was all lame, and it's mostly because they haven't a fucking clue what to do with their completely unfleshed out witch hunter group. And I liked Papa Shango, "You know da rules, no substitutions, Mon. Well, OK, maybe just dis once." *Poof*
I chose to interpret Fiona's reaction as Eminem being a witch too, and that was hilarious. Rest of the episode was all right, not as good as previous seasons but at least we're finally moving past the prologue.
Which is bullshit, Nan was great! "I'm gonna be the nice supreme!"
She's not dead. That was their way of killing Nan without killing Misty first. A brick to the head is way too weak a death for this show.
Which is bullshit, Nan was great! "I'm gonna be the nice supreme!"
So why did 50% of her magic work?
And every character is either evil or insane or both.
Who do we root for if everyone is a villain, lol.
Even considering he a the spirit of the dead, Papa Legba was the nicest character in the episode.
Fantastical
Death Prophet
Also Angela Bassett was fucking horrible in this episode.
Fenderputty
Banned
I don't like where they're taking Fiona's character honestly. I feel like the first two seasons she walked a fine line between evil and good. This time she's just straight evil, but in a petty way, not in a way I can get behind.
It's weird because right now I'm pulling for Zoe and I've not been a fan of her character at all. I'm pulling for Cordelia because her mother is a bitch. Misty is cool, but she's a gullible and innocent to the point of annoyance. Nan was rad, but now she's dead. I enjoyed Angela Bassett when she was an enemy more. Kyle's character could have been left out entirely. I like Delphine, but her finding a small conscience was a lame transition. Bah ... I don't totally dislike this season, but it's not what i was hoping for. Missed potential
You may choose as you wish, but you are choosing to read way too much into that me thinks.
Fenderputty
Banned
Best line in the episode. So random and funny.
~Devil Trigger~
In favor of setting Muslim women on fire
- Status