I could really use some advice, from anybody. Thank you in advance.
Last summer around June, i started talking to this girl but never hung out because we both were out of the state. Fast forward to September, after a little bit of not talking, and we make plans on seeing each other when we get back.
We hangout November 9th and hit it off, we spend the next week hanging out. Everything is going good but then about 3-4 weeks into it, she tells me about this other guy (Guy B) who she's trying to distance herself from. I knew about him before she told me but this confirmed he was important. We had a lot of talks about it. There was Guy A as well but he didn't matter.
Fast forward another couple weeks, she hangs out with Guy B for the "last time" so he could get closure. She goes ghost for 24 hours because she was afraid to tell me what she did. She tells me things changed and she realized she didn't want to cut him out of her life. Fast forward a week, i tell myself that she made her choice, i don't want to deal with that.
So i start hanging out with an old friend. Things move quicker than i expected and she ends up catching feelings for me, which i did too a little bit, she's a sweet girls who respects me more than Girl #1.
And then another week goes by, christmas passes out, and Girl #1 tells me she "cut both of them" out of her life and that she truly wants to be with me. Cool. I blew off Girl #1 on NYE to hang with Girl #2 but i kind of regret it because it gave a wrong impression to #2.
The problem for me is, Girl #2 wants a relationship. Girl #1 wants a relationship **but** she tells me last night that she's been talking to Guy #1 because she felt sad when they weren't friends and she's a little happier that he's back in her life. This irritated me to the max. We had a blowing out last night but agree to talk about everything later tonight, for good or bad. She also responds to Guy #2 sometimes when he texts her because she wants to be on "good terms" with him.
She asked me if i'm trying to dictate who she talks to and i'm not really. I just view this as sort of a respect issue. If i have problems with you talking to someone you had relations with in the past, and you care about me, wouldn't you respect my wish and cease communication? Or am i being too controlling and having personal problems? I wanted to be with Girl #1 originally but i fear that these little things we had thrown at us is a solid indicator of our relationship would be. On the other hand, Girl #2 shows me mutual respect and treats me good but i don't know if i see myself being as happy as i would with Girl #1.
I need to make a decision fast because i don't want to keep dragging people along for nothing.
TLDR: Statted talking to a girl, she had a love triangle going on, i eventually distanced myself, she tells me she wants to be with me, i start having feelings for an old friends, but i really want to be with the original girl who did my wrong but she's still talking with the triangle guys as "friends" because they "bond". Also, original girl is going to start working at my job in a couple weeks.. so.