Thats the thing. Bad players who suck at sniping, do slightly better with AA. Thats ok.
The issue is, great players who rock at sniping are puahwd over the edge with AA. Suddenly theyre quick scoping and taking you out when you revive and just generally unbearable. Its not fun at all.
Removing AA and making it a true weapon of skill would be ok woth me.
Having no AA does not equate to "skill" - I think that's a false equivalency. The controller does not allow the same precision in movement as a mouse. AA is needed for controllers. And I said before, I've played with great players that still dominate consistently.