• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

FANT4STIC 4OUR |OT| Fantastic 4/10

Status
Not open for further replies.
Seeing the way doom is treated makes me sad as he is one of marvels GOAT's.

Thinking of doom I would love if Marvel ever got the rights back give him the "Beasts of no nation" Treatment, Limited release, to not fuck with their phase 3 plans. And then release it on Netflix soon after.

-Have Doom be a ruthless dictator that cares and loves his people
-Treat it like the Nazi's back in WWII where doom goes on a land grab for latveria, and the worlds governments appease him to avoid war.
-Ultron bodies as doombots
-Very serious feel, like Schlinders list, and not jokes every 5 seconds like Age of Ultron
- Explore his relationship with his Gypsy mother and father
-I would love to see Scarlet Witch go back to Sovokia-Latveria and see how doom has changed her people for better or worse.
-How do the avengers react to dooms actions?
-How did doom become doom?
-What is his relationship with Morgan Le Fay?

My Cast Choice
-Cary Fukunaga As Director
-Mads Mikkelson as Doom
-Lars Mikkelson as Prime Minister of Latveria
-Eva Green as Morgan Le Fay
-James Spader as Doombot

It might sound stupid but it cant be any more stupider than this BS we got.
 

Wynnebeck

Banned
Just saw it. Movie went by way too quickly. They spent too much time building up the characters and the rest just rushed by with little to no resolution. Not a good movie.
 

Zeus Molecules

illegal immigrants are stealing our air
Seeing the way doom is treated makes me sad as he is one of marvels GOAT's.

Thinking of doom I would love if Marvel ever got the rights back give him the "Beasts of no nation" Treatment, Limited release, to not fuck with their phase 3 plans. And then release it on Netflix soon after.

-Have Doom be a ruthless dictator that cares and loves his people
-Treat it like the Nazi's back in WWII where doom goes on a land grab for latveria, and the worlds governments appease him to avoid war.
-Ultron bodies as doombots
-Very serious feel, like Schlinders list, and not jokes every 5 seconds like Age of Ultron
- Explore his relationship with his Gypsy mother and father
-I would love to see Scarlet Witch go back to Sovokia-Latveria and see how doom has changed her people for better or worse.
-How do the avengers react to dooms actions?
-How did doom become doom?
-What is his relationship with Morgan Le Fay?

My Cast Choice
-Cary Fukunaga As Director
-Mads Mikkelson as Doom
-Lars Mikkelson as Prime Minister of Latveria
-Eva Green as Morgan Le Fay
-James Spader as Doombot

It might sound stupid but it cant be any more stupider than this BS we got.

I would prefer they introduce Doom in FF (and I agree 100% with your casting for him) and then do a Dr Doom origin/crossover film with Dr Strange based on Triumph and Torment. That series goes a long way of explaining why Doom is the way he is and that he isn't Evil he just doesn't care about anything as long as his goal are accomplished.

Also I just want to put out there in the ether Rami Malek for Reed Richards. Have Reed be an extremely socially awkward genius (like his Mr. Robot character) and show how his interactions with the rest of the FF helps humanize him.
 
I wonder how much better Tranks original vision or the stuff they cut could have made it. I mean its a bad movie no two ways about it, but a few extra bits here and there could have at least made the story more coherent.
 

Dabanton

Member
I think over the next week we'll begin to get more BTS stories about this movie.

I'm fascinated to know who was responsible for what. I haven't listened to that Kevin Smith talk yet. Is Trank going to talk about his version at all? I think Fox are spiteful enough to consider this good enough.

Due to the fanboys going on and on about it Fox no doubt knows the value of the characters they've got. It baffles me why they don't do a Silver Surfer movie. They seem very loathe to go outside of the earth realm.
 

Zeus Molecules

illegal immigrants are stealing our air
I think over the next week we'll begin to get more BTS stories about this movie.

I'm fascinated to know who was responsible for what. I haven't listened to that Kevin Smith talk yet. Is Trank going to talk about his version at all? I think Fox are spiteful enough to consider this good enough.

Due to the fanboys going on and on about it Fox no doubt knows the value of the characters they've got. It baffles me why they don't do a Silver Surfer movie. They seem very loathe to go outside of the earth realm.

Silver surfer is kind of wack without something to ground him. That's is why the 90's cartoon failed, That's why he wasn't able to carry the FF silver surfer movie, hell that's why they had to give him a human girlfriend in the modern comics for it to last for once. Anyhow fans have been talking for years about how great Doom is and we've see what Fox did with that knowledge 3 times.

FF have all the great ancillary characters and villains that could flesh out the MCU, but they aren't an easy sell like the X-Men where its basically a story about discrimination against people because they are different. You got to understand why Doom works, or Kang, or how Galactus and the Silver Surfer tie together to get anything out of them.
 

Hyun Sai

Member
I saw this yesterday with friends, I knew it would be bad, but not THAT bad.

What a mess.

I had a good laugh when I saw the rating of the movie on IMDB : 4/10
 

Mengy

wishes it were bannable to say mean things about Marvel
I decided to combine all the trailers into a 5 minute movie that it is. Spoiler warning since it spoils the entire movie. This is practically everything that happens in the movie in chronological order. Enjoy!

EDIT: FOX don't like me.

https://vid.me/a67s

See, the movie honestly does't look too bad from that montage of footage there. It must be the stuff in between the trailer scenes that truly bring it down.
 
See, the movie honestly does't look too bad from that montage of footage there. It must be the stuff in between the trailer scenes that truly bring it down.

The third act is a turd, that's the issue. Oh and personally I didn't like the first one either, but apparently some gaffers thought it was amazing. To each their own I guess.
 
Movie was dull. Doom is a whiney dork. Clobbering time = knockout game! Shoving your hand in space goo has to be THE stupidest thing I've seen in a while. Fire Flower air freshener on Johny's rearview..

giphy.gif


Man..
 
Why is ben so absent from the movie? Theres a pretty wide gap between him dropping reed off at university, then him coming back.

And what the hell kind of writing is it, where the only reason ben is there and gets powers at all is cos Reed calls him when they get wasted? Sure we're supposed to know theyre best mates, but they've had barely any screen time together.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
I heard of some kind of final suits, are blue suits in this?

And ah man, this thread makes me want to reread Ultimate Fantastic Four...
 

Slayven

Member
I fucking WISH I was paid to watch that shit..the only good thing was it wasn't on my dime. Don't know if I should thank my friends, or clobbering time them..

One of the dudes I follow on twitter sounded so crushed after watching it. Like a parent goes past being mad to just being disappointed and can't even talk to the kid cause the kid fucked up that bad.
 

Garlador

Member
I've never seen this type of thing before. This movie is going down in flames. All the reviews seem to be stuck in the negative zone. Maybe Fox just stretched the property too far. The chances of any sequels are vanishing by the minute. But let's be honest, it was doomed from the start.

... I just needed to get that out of my system.
 
I've never seen this type of thing before. This movie is going down in flames. All the reviews seem to be stuck in the negative zone. Maybe Fox just stretched the property too far. The chances of any sequels are vanishing by the minute. But let's be honest, it was doomed from the start.

... I just needed to get that out of my system.

You could say the movie is getting clobbered?
 

munchie64

Member
The screen writer's tweets make me feel for many.
There's not a ton of my stuff left in the movie (mostly the 1st act), but I'll always be honored that I got to play in such a cool sandbox.
I grew up with these characters. Got in fights over these characters. Burned through my allowance buying every single issue that came out.
So getting the chance to write for Ben, for Victor, for Reed & Sue and Johnny…I mean, holy shit. You have no idea how much that meant to me.
At the end of the day, we tried to do something new and ambitious, something that respected the source material without being beholden to it
It’s up to you to decide whether or not we succeeded. But I hope you give the film a chance. And I hope you like what you see.

But then things get better.
 

Garlador

Member
Serious question, is it worse than Catwoman?
Serious response:

That depends. Catwoman is SO bad, it's GLORIOUS. It's a fascinating failure of a movie that does literally everything wrong and entertains me from start to finish in the same way that "The Room" does.

Fant4stic, however, is not so much bad as it is DULL. It's not even "so bad it's good". It does some things well, even, but it's so much less memorable that, ultimately, it's worse than being "bad"; it's utterly boring and forgettable.
 

borghe

Loves the Greater Toronto Area
Saw this yesterday. Inclined to believe the rumors and Trank's Twitter rant.

First half of the movie was actually.... Really good. Like as in I really have nothing negative to say and it actually went in a cool direction with the origin. I found myself thinking "wtf is wrong with people? This is great!!"

Then after Reed escaped it turned into a wholy different, very boring, very generic super hero movie with a stupid looking Doom. It's been a while since I've watched a movie this schizophrenic. Would be amazing if there was an original cut somewhere of the second half before Fox fucked it up.

Not worth going to the theater for, but seriously... When this hits Netflix do yourself a favor and watch the first 45 mins or so. Marvel could even take notes from it on a possible reboot of the comic.

Teenage daughter summed it up best (without knowing any of the gossip) "I just never cared about any of them, which is weird.. Because it started off with them connecting, and becoming friends and a family and caring about each other, and then it just stopped when they got back to earth.. And no one cared about anyone anymore, which I guess I stopped caring also.."

Fucking Fox.
 
$26.2 million opening weekend... fuck, this put the biggest smile on my face.

That Cruise missile wrecked this steaming pile and rightfully so.

FOX is in panic mode and if it did this bad opening weekend, think of the second week drop off... man, this is BOMBA defined right here.
 
It seems way more plausible to me that instead of it simply being "TRANK FUCKED THE DOG" or "THE STUDIO FUCKED TRANK" (because it's usually never that easy) - looking at the rumors (reddit/collider), the reports (Hollywood Reporter/EW), the tweets (Trank/Landis/Slater), that we have a situation where:

Trank got a lot of faith placed in him and a lot of pressure placed on him.
He was told that setpieces needed to come out because they were too expensive
The resultant scramble to replace content stressed him the fuck out
The resultant stress caused him to act out
The acting out caused a lack of faith in him
The lack of faith and bad behavior meant he essentially had to be replaced
The people who had to replace him before the clock ran out couldn't come up with any ideas that were worth a shit
Those ideas weren't executed well because nobody still there had any faith left in the project
Those bad ideas, poorly executed, dragged down what good ideas were still there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom