• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Official Doctor Who Series 1, 5, 31, or Fnarg Thread of Moffat & Smith

Status
Not open for further replies.
Subliminal said:
Oh fuck.

Some RTD Bullshit coming up? Maybe everyone on earth will think that he has more regenerations therefore he will get some

SFX said:
But my favourite bit of the whole story was a cheeky exchange between Clyde and the Doctor, which puts the lid on a couple of fanboy debates that have been raging for decades in the space of a couple of lines – that is, if you take what the Doctor says seriously. The thought that one of these lines could soon be “officially canon” is extremely amusing…

Also, when the Doctor closed all the cracks in the universe he apparently closed the Cardiff rift as well - hence why Torchwood have no reason to stay there.
 
Dr Zhivago said:
Also, when the Doctor closed all the cracks in the universe he apparently closed the Cardiff rift as well - hence why Torchwood have no reason to stay there.

Interesting... now how is he going to fuel the TARDIS?
No Time Lords - No Eye of Harmony
No Cardiff Rift - No easy energy pitstop...


...hmn...
 
Dr Zhivago said:
Also, when the Doctor closed all the cracks in the universe he apparently closed the Cardiff rift as well - hence why Torchwood have no reason to stay there.

Rift =/= Crack surely?!

I think the reason they are going is the torchwood blowing up thing from the last torchwood season. The rift should still be there.
 
Subliminal said:
Rift =/= Crack surely?!

I think the reason they are going is the torchwood blowing up thing from the last torchwood season. The rift should still be there.

It's what Davies says in the new SFX. I suspect they won't reference it explicitly, though.
 

Mr. Sam

Member
Dr Zhivago said:
It's what Davies says in the new SFX. I suspect they won't reference it explicitly, though.
Moffat went to a lot of effort to retcon RTD's tosh. How dare he try to tie it back together!
 
JonathanEx said:
Doctor Who on Wii and DS!
Worth noting there was already a Doctor Who game of sorts on Wii. Based on a licensed edition of a card game.
120479-large.jpg
 

Thomper

Member
Subliminal said:
mm.

I really like what they're doing with the Christmas episode. it really feels like an extension of the story and there is actual mystery as to whats going to happen. unlike EVERY RTD Christmas episode.
... but we know nothing about this Christmas-episode yet. Moffat said it'll be the most Christmassy Christmas-thing ever in the history of Who, and that it'll have Michael Gambon, but besides that... nothing? Did I miss something about it being an 'extension of the story'? I also prefer most of Moffat's stuff over most of RTD's stuff, but bashing RTD without having really seen anything of Moffat's Christmas-story seems a bit unfair.
 
JoshuaJSlone said:
Worth noting there was already a Doctor Who game of sorts on Wii. Based on a licensed edition of a card game.
http://www.lovefilm.com/lovefilm/images/products/9/120479-large.jpg[img][/QUOTE]

Everytime I see that box art I feel they gave up half way through making it, and never put anyone beside Tennent even though they had planned to...

Would be a good Photoshop thread :)
 

Seraphis Cain

bad gameplay lol
Just started Series 3 last night/this morning. First impression of Martha is...she's okay, I guess. The Christmas Special really made me like Donna, though, so I'm really looking forward to Series 4.
 
Seraphis Cain said:
Just started Series 3 last night/this morning. First impression of Martha is...she's okay, I guess. The Christmas Special really made me like Donna, though, so I'm really looking forward to Series 4.

End of Season 3 is great, you'll love it. Very exciting, hard hitting, emotional, and raw.
 
Seraphis Cain said:
The Christmas Special really made me like Donna, though, so I'm really looking forward to Series 4.
I've never heard anyone say that about Donna in The Runaway Bride. The endless SHOUTING is still burned into my brain. Anyway, if you like her now, you'll LOVE her in season 4.

Keyser Soze said:
End of Season 3 is great, you'll love it. Very exciting, hard hitting, emotional, and raw.
:lol
 

Staccat0

Fail out bailed
I adore Donna. My favorite companion. I like how obnoxious she is. Most of the companions are just pleasant little doggies that follow the doctor around and worship him. It was neat for him to have a more rowdy foil.
I think GAF has a long enough track record of having terrible taste in female characters (Skylar & Betty hate for example) that I would be willing to wager most of GAF hates Donna?

Amy is a nice mix of Rose and Donna IMO. I'm guessing she'll be my fave in the end because she is also the hottest:lol
 
Staccat0 said:
I adore Donna. My favorite companion. I like how obnoxious she is. Most of the companions are just pleasant little doggies that follow the doctor around and worship him. It was neat for him to have a more rowdy foil.
I'd say she is my favourite companion as well, which is amazing considering how much i disliked her in The Runaway Bride.
I think GAF has a long enough track record of having terrible taste in female characters (Skylar & Betty hate for example) that I would be willing to wager most of GAF hates Donna?
There were still Tate detractors in the season 4 thread, but by the end most had come around to her.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
I hated Donna.

I'd rank the new companions

S1 Rose > Amy > S2 Rose = Martha > Donna.

I like Martha even with her bad episodes. She had the potential to be an awesome companion. The story with her being a rebound character for the Doctor could have worked better (I don't think that part of S3's story was all that bad) and I also liked that she's the only companion from new Who who wasn't running away from a mundane life to be with the Doctor.
 

Mr. Sam

Member
Still despise Martha because of the mediocre actress that Freema was. Her family was suitably entirely composed of similarly mediocre actors.
 

Zenith

Banned
So no one interested in the new Dr Who game? It explains all the TARDIS controls.

Helm panel

2s785xy.jpg


1. Eyepiece

Doctor: If the external scanners aren't working, the Eyepiece works as an optical viewfinder, with a much more limited view than the scanners.

Amy: It's a bit like the viewfinder on a cheap camera.

2. Space/Time Throttle

Doctor: This adjusts the speed of travel through space and time, either separately or simultaneously.

Amy: Looks like a throttle on a plane. I went on a simulator once, it was brilliant. I can use this to go faster or slower.

3. Time Rotor Handbrake

Doctor: Immediately stops the TARDIS from travelling through time. Unless you're going too fast, then you'll skid for a bit. Er, apparently...

Amy: This has to be the handbrake, it looks like one anyway. Only one way to find out.


Navigation panel

9qjpjb.jpg


1. Time and Space Forward/Back Control

Doctor: Forwards or backwards, pretty self explanatory really. I think that's what it's for, anyway.

Amy: Only moves forwards or backwards. That must be all it does. Doesn't this thing have gears?

2. Directional Pointer

Doctor: Orients the TARDIS in space, letting you turn in any direction. Yeah, when it's working of course.

Amy: This spins the TARDIS round, great - like it doesn't do enough of that! How do I know which way is up?

3. Atom Acclerator

Doctor: This provides the energy for travelling through time and space. It's supposed to be powered up before using the Space/Time Throttle.

Amy: No idea what this is, but when I turn it, I can hear something powering up. Must be important.

4. Spatial Location Input

Doctor: This enables you to choose an exact place in physical space to travel to without all that tricky steering.

Amy: A proper keyboard! If I type in where I want to go, will it take me there?


Diagnostic panel

1jug3o.jpg


1. Inertial Dampers

Doctor: These compensate for the speed of travel, and stop us getting thrown around. In theory, anyway. Must get them fixed...

Amy: I've seen the Doctor using these to stop things shaking around so much. But I don't think they're working too well...

2. Cooling Systems

Doctor: The engines generate a lot of heat when in use, and require a sophisticated cooling system to stop them overheating.

Amy: That looks like it keeps an eye on the engine temperature. Must stop things overheating.

3. Bunsen Burner

Doctor: Used for heating or burning test samples, in the event of the scanner being unable to identify a substance. Or for boiling water. Sometimes I just fancy a nice cup of tea and a jammy dodger.

Amy: A bunsen burner! Just like in Chemistry at school. I heated the wrong beaker, and smoked out the school for a day. It was brilliant.

4. Mic/Water Dispenser

Doctor: The microphone is for the voice recorder, and broadcasting messages. The water dispenser is for diluting samples for testing. Although if I'm being honest, the water dispenser is mainly used for filling the kettle.

Amy: Don't know what this is for, but I've seen the Doctor fill the kettle from it. Surely it can't just be for that?


Communication panel

dx1hua.jpg


1. Digital Com

Doctor: A device for communicating with other spacecraft, or anything with a digital transceiver.

Amy: Communications. We've had people contact us through this before.

2. Analogue Telephone

Doctor: This enables people with older forms of communication to contact me. No matter where the TARDIS is, the call will connect.

Amy: It's a telephone! Just an ordinary telephone. Well, not that ordinary - we got a call from Winston Churchill once. Yes, that Winston Churchill!

3. Voice Recorder

Doctor: A device for recording audio messages. Usually to myself, so I don't forget things. I'm almost as absent-minded as Albert Einstein. He'd forget his head if it wasn't firmly attached but that's another story...

Amy: Looks like the world's oldest dictaphone.

4. Analogue Radio Waves Detect/Monitor/Change

Doctor: For receiving and transmitting radio waves. It can also alter them without the sender realising it.

Amy: Sounds like some sort of radio thingy. You know, for such a new TARDIS, it's got a lot of old junk.

5. Scanner/Typewriter

Doctor: This examines and analyses any substance in the vicinity. It's also a very good typewriter, when it's got a fresh ribbon.

Amy: This can't just be a typewriter, I've seen the Doctor scanning stuff with it before. Looks like it needs a new ribbon too.


Fabricator panel

j58nbs.jpg


1. Harmonic Generator

Doctor: This creates resonant harmonics where the TARDIS is about to materialise or dematerialise, so it doesn't cause too much disturbance. And by "disturbance", I mean a massive sonic boom, and a 4-dimensional crisis. Not good, in other words.

Amy: This must be important, the Doctor always uses it before using the appeary/disappeary thingy. Everything goes a bit wobbly when it's on.

2. Materialise/Dematerialise function

Doctor: This engages the engines, and makes the TARDIS disappear and reappear. Leave the handbrake on, it makes a lovely sound.

Amy: I definitely know this - it's the one that makes the TARDIS appear and disappear. It's the last thing the Doctor uses before we start moving.

3. Time Altimeter

Doctor: It's tricky to know exactly when "now" is during time travel. This displays how fast the TARDIS is going.

Amy: This one only seems to move when we're moving through time. Must be a time speedometer or something like that.

4. Fabricated Dispenser

Doctor: The TARDIS can create devices of its own, like a new Sonic Screwdriver. It takes a lot of time and energy, though.

Amy: I saw the Doctor make a new Sonic Screwdriver out of this. I'm going to call it the Makey Uppy Thingy.

5. Heisenberg Focusing Device

Doctor: You can observe a subatomic particle's position and state, but never both at once. This device compensates for that.

Amy: Another control the Doctor seems to mess around with at random. I don't think he actually knows how to fly this thing.


Mechanical panel

2jdi4iu.jpg


1. Engine Release Lever

Doctor: When the engines are fully powered up, this engages the gears and lets them control the TARDIS.

Amy: This is the very last thing the Doctor uses before we appear or disappear. I think it's the gear, it seems to trigger the engines.

2. Door Release Lever

Doctor: Locks and unlocks the doors. I'm always forgetting and walking into them.

Amy: I've used this before, it locks and unlocks the doors. Easy.

3. TARDIS Display Dials

Doctor: From left to right, these display engine cycles per second, engine temperature, time rotor speed and exterior temperature.

Amy: Hmm, display dials. I'm going to ignore those, unless they go into the danger area, then I'll start pressing buttons.

4. Gyroscopic Stabliser

Doctor: When the Inertial Dampers aren't powerful enough, this will stabalise the TARDIS and keep it upright while travelling. Supposedly.

Amy: I think this keeps the TARDIS the right way up when we're getting flung about. We could do with a few more of them really.

5. Locking Down Mechanism

Doctor: A handbrake to stop the TARDIS travelling in physical space. Don't forget the Time handbrake too, or she'll drift off in time.

Amy: The Doctor uses this after we've stopped. There's a Time handbrake, maybe this is the normal handbrake?
 
BBC Press Release:

Next series of Doctor Who to be split transmission

The BBC and Steven Moffat have announced today that the transmission of the next series of Doctor Who, in 2011, will be split into two blocks, transmitting in spring and autumn.

The split transmission is the result of a request from Steven Moffat to write a new Doctor Who story arc which involves a big plot twist in the middle of the series. By splitting the series Moffat plans to give viewers one of the most exciting Doctor Who cliffhangers and plot twists ever, leaving them waiting, on the edge of their seats, until the autumn to find out what happens.

Steven Moffat said: "The split series is hugely exciting because viewers will be treated to two premieres, two finales and more event episodes. For the kids it will never be more than a few months to the next Doctor Who! Easter, Autumn, Christmas!!"
 

Thomper

Member
Curious to see if this means this will be what every series will be like from Series 6 on, or if this is a sneaky way to move Doctor Who to autumn without there being a long, long gap of no Doctor Who-episodes.
 
What the shit is this ? I guess the rumour that
Amy is leaving half way through the series is true then
. Must be some BBC shenanigans.


Who in the autumn will be good though.
 
More from The Guardian, in which Moffat confirms that Spring is Series 6, and Autumn is Series 7.

The new series of Doctor Who will be split into two for the first time, with its showrunner, Steven Moffat, promising the show's biggest ever cliffhanger – "an earth-shattering climax".
Next year's 13-part series, the sixth since Doctor Who returned in 2005, will run for seven episodes and then return in the autumn for another six.
Moffat said the Easter "mid-season finale" would be a "game-changing cliffhanger".
He added that next year's Doctor Who would run as two separate series, allowing him to double the number of "event episodes" in the new run, and meant fans would never be more than a few months away from the next instalment of the hit BBC1 show.
"Looking at the next series I thought what this show needs is a big event in the middle," Moffat told the Media Guardian Edinburgh International Television Festival.
"I kept referring to a mid-season finale. So we are going to make it two series – seven episodes at Easter building to an earth-shattering climax, a cliffhanger we could never normally do because it would be too long before it came back. An enormous game-changing cliffhanger that will change everything.
"The wrong expression would be to say we are splitting it in two. We are making it two separate series."

There's more at the link.
 
I have grown to hate this stuff on US TV, and am pissed it is making its way into UK shows. Complete bullshit IMO. The sooner this guy gives up the reigns to the show the better, as he is just ruining what Russell T Davis spent years of blood sweat and tears building up.
 
Mr. Sam said:
So I'll have to make a Series 2, 6, 32 or Otter thread and a Series 3, 7, 33 or ??? thread?

One big thread....

Official Doctor Who Series 2, 6, 32, or Otter and 3, 7, 33 or Lutra Thread of Moffat, Smith, Gillen, and Jenkins in a 2011 extravaganza. Fezes are cool. We are so sorry. Wibbly Wobbly Timey Wimey.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Amir0x said:
oh boy i hate when people hype up cliffhangers

Especially since they all pale in comparison to the ultimate cliffhanger.

Locutus_on_viewscreen.jpg


Loved Stewart's comments that people would tell him that he ruined their summer that year. :lol
 

Shanadeus

Banned
Eh, so it's just one 7 episode series and one 6 series one?
Would have been impressive the total number of episodes had been increased, even if it meant just 8+8 or 9+9 episodes.
 

Thomper

Member
Shanadeus said:
Eh, so it's just one 7 episode series and one 6 series one?
Would have been impressive the total number of episodes had been increased, even if it meant just 8+8 or 9+9 episodes.
Takes them about 9 or 10 months already to film the 14 episodes a year they have to film now. The people involved with the show still want to have the chance to do *some* other stuff as well, so don't think you'll ever see more.
 
Shanadeus said:
Eh, so it's just one 7 episode series and one 6 series one?
Would have been impressive the total number of episodes had been increased, even if it meant just 8+8 or 9+9 episodes.

This is British TV dude. Not gonna happen. :lol
 

Shanadeus

Banned
Thomper said:
Takes them about 9 or 10 months already to film the 14 episodes a year they have to film now. The people involved with the show still want to have the chance to do *some* other stuff as well, so don't think you'll ever see more.
I'll just hope for one more episode 2012

*hopes*
 

Thomper

Member
Dr Zhivago said:
Interesting. Presumably this means they can avoid it going against Britain's Got X Factor Celebrity Ice Dance Makeover Idol.
Think it's also to make it not air all the way into summer. The ratings were getting really low by the end of last season, while the ratings share was still pretty high. Just so happened that very few people were watching TV in the middle of summer, when the finale was airing. And as Easter is three weeks later this year, maybe they decided this was a good year to start shifting over Doctor Who to autumn, where good weather is less of a problem.
 
Dr Zhivago said:
Interesting. Presumably this means they can avoid it going against Britain's Got X Factor Celebrity Ice Dance Makeover Idol.

I was thinking the opposite really, X Factor and Strictly are just kicking into gear now, and will be going full force all the way to Xmas. So, if Doctor Who is in the Autumn next year it will have to deal with themf ro the final 6 episodes.

Currently the go up against Britain Got Talent in the spring, which hurts them a bit, but if they ever get placed opposite of a big late season X-factor show, then the ratings will plummet. Hopefully, X-Factor continues to fight with Strictly Come Dancing, and never goes head to head with Who.

One good thing is that they will now probably not air shows when the UK gets its bit of decent weather in the summer, so no one will choose going out to lie in the sun over Who any more.
 

Thomper

Member
Keyser Soze said:
I was thinking the opposite really, X Factor and Strictly are just kicking into gear now, and will be going full force all the way to Xmas. So, if Doctor Who is in the Autumn next year it will have to deal with themf ro the final 6 episodes.

Currently the go up against Britain Got Talent in the spring, which hurts them a bit, but if they ever get placed opposite of a big late season X-factor show, then the ratings will plummet. Hopefully, X-Factor continues to fight with Strictly Come Dancing, and never goes head to head with Who.

One good thing is that they will now probably not air shows when the UK gets its bit of decent weather in the summer, so no one will choose going out to lie in the sun over Who any more.
Saw someone comment that they could also put the show on Sunday in autumn. It worked really well for Waters of Mars.

(Plus, if this means there's a Sunday in autumn that will have Doctor Who, followed by Top Gear, followed by Sherlock, that's probably the best line-up of anything, ever.)
 
Amir0x said:
oh boy i hate when people hype up cliffhangers

I do to but I have a feeling Moffat isn't jerking us around. He's a very straight forward guy. My theory, this has something to do with the regeneration limit as well as revealing the "silence will fall" guy/girl.
 

DKehoe

Gold Member
So I was at the event today in which Steven Moffat talked about this. They actually showed the trailer for the christmas special as well.
 

OMG Aero

Member
Mama Robotnik said:
Moffat plans to give viewers one of the most exciting Doctor Who cliffhangers and plot twists ever, leaving them waiting, on the edge of their seats, until the autumn to find out what happens
Oh dick move Moffat.
Like it wasn't already hard enough waiting a week for the last episode after seeing the first part.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom