I think your expectations should be kept in check. It's a good cheesecake, but it's not going to blow your mind. All the negative reviews I've read were basically people that thought it was going to change the way they saw cheesecakes, or something. Or they were upset they had to wait so long.
When I go back, I'll basically see how long the line is. 45 minutes, or a hour, I can handle, but one of the 2 hour plus lines.. yeah, no thanks. But for $10, I actually think it's a good value. Just depends how much time you have to burn.