• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PoliGAF 2015-2016 |OT3| If someone named PhoenixDark leaves your party, call the cops

Status
Not open for further replies.

danm999

Member
The establishment getting behind Rubio in a big way is a good idea in concept but the execution is riddled with potential disasters.
 
Did Jeb! even give a speech tonight? I didn't see it covered on CNN/MSNBC or anything. I mean....I'm not sure his momma would have shown up for it, but....still. Did he?

I'm sure there were like 3 or 4 trust fund Frat boys who worked on his campaign and were heartbroken he didn't win.
 
It's possible that Trump looming large and being somewhat general election toxic, probably freed people to think "Screw it, we'll win whoever we pick." So if there's any consolation to Rubiomentum for $hillaries, his rise might lead to a reassessment of priorities.
 
I can't imagine the Bernie fans think he can still win a general right? Sanders vs Rubio? That's Mondale vs Reagan all over again.

Hills as vp. Ta-daaaa!

Then you just gotta wait until she finda a way to kill him.

Yes, millions of pissed of bigots will now evaporate into thin air because Trump took second in a state he never should have been competitive in in the first place.

The Diablosing is strong tonight.

Seeing first hand why blue dogs used to be so successful.
 
I can't imagine the Bernie fans think he can still win a general right? Sanders vs Rubio? That's Mondale vs Reagan all over again.
I wouldn't go that far. Rubio is no Reagan by any stretch and Bernie has a lot more things in his favor than Mondale did. Biggest one being that the country isn't nearly as conservative as it was 36 years ago

I think Bernie would probably lose but there's still a chance he would win. But obviously the odds on that make me feel like it's an unecessary risk.
 
Rubio could still quite easily get killed over immigration by... pretty much everyone running. Also watch for the deer-in-the-headlights look if he really starts to turn into the party golden boy.
 

Diablos

Member
unless something magical happens in 7 days, Trump and Sanders will crush NH
Something magical kind of did happen. Hillary and Sanders basically canceled each other out and Rubio is gaining traction fast. This could completely change the dynamic in NH and set up Rubio for a win, or second place with Trump falling to third.

More Dems voted in SC primary than GOP did in 2008. That sure helped.
SC Isn't a swing state the last time I chceked. IA is.


Anyone even remotely advocating for a Sanders nomination being safe up against the GOP, particularly Rubio, is not thinking this through. It will definitely smell like Mondale vs. Reagan. Would the loss be as profound for Sanders? Probably not due to demographics changes. But there is no fucking way Bernie is a safe bet for winning the GE. Not even close.

Last night was great for the GOP and bad for Democrats. I'm growing concerned that the Democratic voterbase (at least half of them) are failing to see the big picture. Bernie supporters remind me of a key sect of Obama's base that seem to be under some kind of spell and thus have lost all of their common sense as they blindly follow Bernie and forget about outside factors (i.e. what matters, winning the White House).

btw if Bernie comes out as an atheist/agnostic soon then he's even dumber than I thought when it comes to campaigning. I am not religious myself but he's going to give the GOP a huge gift if he does that.

I really wish he would get out of the way. The party doesn't want him, he can't win, all he's doing is providing false hope to young people because he simply is not Presidential material.
 

danm999

Member
Rubio could still quite easily get killed over immigration by... pretty much everyone running. Also watch for the deer-in-the-headlights look if he really starts to turn into the party golden boy.

And if Trump feels like the party is getting too behind someone not named Trump, he might flip the table over and run third party.
 

Tesseract

Banned
scooby dooby gloopy gooby, we're so fucked

CZmJ_MIUsAA5GKP.jpg:large
 
POS Trump better start spending his damn money on stuff, because now with all these results coming in the media isn't going to do his job for him nearly as much anymore and half assing it isn't going to work
 

danm999

Member
scooby dooby gloopy gooby, we're so fucked

CZmJ_MIUsAA5GKP.jpg:large

Oh yeah?

150226214526-inhofe-snowball-senate-floor-00000516-exlarge-169.jpg


Checkmate liberals.

POS Trump better start spending his damn money on stuff, because now with all these results coming in the media isn't going to do his job for him nearly as much anymore and half assing it isn't going to work

Politico ran a story (titled Donald Trump, 2016's first loser lol) that basically implies Trump cheaped out big time in Iowa.

Cruz’s campaign, for instance, in the last three months of 2015 racked up $3.6 million in bills from a data firm called Cambridge Analytica that builds what it calls “psychographic” profiles of voters to try to win them over with narrowly targeted micro-messages. Sources say the firm, which is owned by one of Cruz’s biggest donors, has embedded multiple staffers within the campaign to work with a substantial in-house data operation.

A source said the Trump campaign balked at the price tag associated with Cambridge Analytica’s services.

Instead, Trump’s data shop is headed by a pair of low-profile former RNC data engineers, Matt Braynard and Witold Chrabaszcz, who are regarded as technically savvy but who do not have previous high-level campaign experience. And, while Trump’s team late last year entered into an agreement with the political data outfit L2, the campaign has only paid the firm $235,000 for “research consulting” through the end of 2015, the period covered by the most recent Federal Election Commission reports.

Trump’s reports show that his self-funded campaign has spent relatively little on voter data or outreach. They showed $200,000 in list rental payments to the conservative Newsmax Media, and $47,000 to Targeted Victory, a leading GOP digital firm, as well as $700,000 on field staff and consultants.

By contrast, the campaign has spent at least $1.2 million on hats ― presumably mostly for the now-iconic hats bearing Trump’s campaign slogan “Make America Great Again.”
 
The thing is, Trump got 24% in Iowa seemingly without having any kind of real ground game. He only finished 3% behind a guy who is tailor-made for the state. That's not really that shabby, and it suggests to me he could be pretty formidable if he starts upping his spending significantly in subsequent states, which he probably will unless he really doesn't give a shit about being President and has just been doing this as some kind of weird publicity stunt for nothing.
 

CCS

Banned
Clinton should really own the coin toss thing, just run with it. Imagine:

"America, do you want to vote for an unlucky candidate, or a lucky one?"

Cuts to shot of Clinton balling in Vegas.
 

tmarg

Member
The thing is, Trump got 24% in Iowa seemingly without having any kind of real ground game. He only finished 3% behind a guy who is tailor-made for the state. That's not really that shabby, and it suggests to me he could be pretty formidable if he starts upping his spending significantly in subsequent states, which he probably will unless he really doesn't give a shit about being President and has just been doing this as some kind of weird publicity stunt for nothing.

Yeah. The panic here is really weird. The establishment candidates lost by a more than 2-1 margin, and Rubio took third in a caucus system that effectively forced establishment votes to consolidate behind him because their other candidates wouldn't meet the 15% threshold.

Until Rubio shows that he can convert the voters who consider nominating an outsider to be their highest priority, I don't see a path to victory for him.
 

Plinko

Wildcard berths that can't beat teams without a winning record should have homefield advantage
The thing is, Trump got 24% in Iowa seemingly without having any kind of real ground game. He only finished 3% behind a guy who is tailor-made for the state. That's not really that shabby, and it suggests to me he could be pretty formidable if he starts upping his spending significantly in subsequent states, which he probably will unless he really doesn't give a shit about being President and has just been doing this as some kind of weird publicity stunt for nothing.

Seriously, the Diablosing in this thread is insane. Trump did cheap out on Iowa. Why? He wasn't expected to compete here from the beginning. It was a miracle he got second place in that state.

Sure, if Trump drops like 25 points in a week and loses New Hampshire, then start freaking out. At this point, though? Come on.

As tmarg said above, think about the establishment vote--it almost ALL went to him. He still got third. You really think if Trump drops out, Rubio gets his voters? Seriously?
 

danm999

Member
Seriously, the Diablosing in this thread is insane. Trump did cheap out on Iowa. Why? He wasn't expected to compete here from the beginning. It was a miracle he got second place in that state

Hey, that's all Politico, I still think Trump has it over on Rubio.
 

NeoXChaos

Member
a state that trump came close to winning with terrible demographics for him somehow cost us to diablos. Wait for NH people.

Did Hillary win?
 

Y2Kev

TLG Fan Caretaker Est. 2009
People are diablosing because he underperformed and Rubio seriously over performed. Now there are legitimate questions about the firmness of Trump's support but more importantly whether or not a rapid congealing of the old farts behind Rubio will render trump a loser.

Seltzer blew ass last night and that's fine, but Rubio seriously sent a message last night and people should be afraid.

Maybe it won't matter in NH because all of the losers are still present, but in NV, SC, Rubio will basically pick up 10% of the vote. If you believe trumps support is weak, then that is a concern.

Not to mention media spin over the next week will be brutal to trump.
 

benjipwns

Banned
Yeah. The panic here is really weird. The establishment candidates lost by a more than 2-1 margin, and Rubio took third in a caucus system that effectively forced establishment votes to consolidate behind him because their other candidates wouldn't meet the 15% threshold.
There was no threshold. Carson and Rand Paul are getting delegates.
 

Cheebo

Banned
It's crazy to see the Bernie fans in the OT crying that caucuses are undemocratic and unfair. Man how things have really switched places.
 
It's crazy to see the Bernie fans in the OT crying that caucuses are undemocratic and unfair. Man how things have really switched places.

I'm still bitter about 2008, so I'll give them the benefit of the doubt. I don't like caucuses. It's not that their undemocratic, but it adds a layer of complexity to voting. It's not fair to those who have to work, or can only find transportation at specific times. I would love to see them all go away and be replaced with a primary. I feel it's just more fair.
 

tmarg

Member
People are diablosing because he underperformed and Rubio seriously over performed. Now there are legitimate questions about the firmness of Trump's support but more importantly whether or not a rapid congealing of the old farts behind Rubio will render trump a loser.

Maybe it won't matter in NH because all of the losers are still present, but in NV, SC, Rubio will basically pick up 10% of the vote. If you believe trumps support is weak, then that is a concern.

Not to mention media spin over the next week will be brutal to trump.

Even if we assume that a Trump collapse is imminent (which I don't, but whatever), you still have to explain how all his voters end up supporting Rubio, the republican candidate they are the least likely to line up behind, with the possible exception of JEB.
 

Cheebo

Banned
I'm still bitter about 2008, so I'll give them the benefit of the doubt. I don't like caucuses. It's not that their undemocratic, but it adds a layer of complexity to voting. It's not fair to those who have to work, or can only find transportation at specific times. I would love to see them all go away and be replaced with a primary. I feel it's just more fair.

I agree, but it was no secret they didn't go away in 2016 and Hillary's campaign knew they had to game the caucus system just like Obama did. Any Bernie fans taken by surprise and upset have only themselves to blame. This info has been out there. For years.

Even if we assume that a Trump collapse is imminent (which I don't, but whatever), you still have to explain how all his voters end up supporting Rubio, the republican candidate they are the least likely to line up behind, with the possible exception of JEB.

Entrance polling in Iowa showed a lot of former Trump supporters ended up going to Rubio in the end.
 

PBY

Banned
People are diablosing because he underperformed and Rubio seriously over performed. Now there are legitimate questions about the firmness of Trump's support but more importantly whether or not a rapid congealing of the old farts behind Rubio will render trump a loser.

Seltzer blew ass last night and that's fine, but Rubio seriously sent a message last night and people should be afraid.

Maybe it won't matter in NH because all of the losers are still present, but in NV, SC, Rubio will basically pick up 10% of the vote. If you believe trumps support is weak, then that is a concern.

Not to mention media spin over the next week will be brutal to trump.
Yeah the media has me shook.

The narrative is all that Trump is a huge loser. Questioning his support and organization.


This is a massive L brehs.
 
Yeah. The panic here is really weird. The establishment candidates lost by a more than 2-1 margin, and Rubio took third in a caucus system that effectively forced establishment votes to consolidate behind him because their other candidates wouldn't meet the 15% threshold.

Until Rubio shows that he can convert the voters who consider nominating an outsider to be their highest priority, I don't see a path to victory for him.
There isn't a threshold for the Republican field from memory? The others were just losers because they're sucky losers.
 

benjipwns

Banned
In all this Democratic hype everyone is ignoring that there's still ONE GOP PRECINCT unreported.

JIM GILMORE MIGHT HAVE 13 OR MORE VOTES
 

Maledict

Member
Yup.

Everyone dumping on Trump. Not a lot of Cruz talk

It's the Santorum effect. The media have basically written off Iowa's first choice in the republican race, because their first choice is usually insane. Iowa's purpose is now to judge the establishment candidates strength and give them the electability platform for the following states.

Winning Iowa doesn't matter on the R side, it's all about expectations.
 

Jarmel

Banned
It just seems insane to me that people would want Sanders if Rubio is starting to shape up to be the nom on the Repub side. I have to imagine that would be a bloodbath.
 

Diablos

Member
It's crazy to see the Bernie fans in the OT crying that caucuses are undemocratic and unfair. Man how things have really switched places.
They're throwing a wrench into everything. I have such a bad feeling about this. Bernie is in it for the long haul.

All the more reason why I wish Biden would have run. Even if he would have lost in the end he would have pushed Bernie to third most likely.
 

thefro

Member
They're throwing a wrench into everything. I have such a bad feeling about this. Bernie is in it for the long haul.

All the more reason why I wish Biden would have run. Even if he would have lost in the end he would have pushed Bernie to third most likely.

Drudge is pushing the narrative that Clinton only won because of the coin flips.
 

dramatis

Member
In all this Democratic hype everyone is ignoring that there's still ONE GOP PRECINCT unreported.

JIM GILMORE MIGHT HAVE 13 OR MORE VOTES
I'd say, the real winner of the Iowa caucus is Jim Gilmore. He said he would count even one vote for him as a victory, so Jim Gilmore actually won more times than any other candidate!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom