• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PoliGAF 2016 |OT7| Notorious R.B.G. Plans NZ Tour

Status
Not open for further replies.

Iolo

Member
There was this girl on the BBC World Service on my NPR station a few minutes ago that basically proved that young people are stupid everywhere, not just in the US. Shit like this was falling out of her mouth:

The media gravitates to stupid people and outliers everywhere. Otherwise they wouldn't be on TV.
 

Maledict

Member
Personal bit.

I've been through many elections in my life. Some were triumphs where it felt like the entire country was coming together in one voice - 1997. Some were sad gasps of despair where I honestly wondered how we could be here - 2015.

But none have ever hit me like the EU referendum result. I'm going to borrow the language of the right wing here - I honestly don't feel like this is my country anymore, and I want it back. We've made a decision that fundamentally alters everything about our place in the world and our future based on lies, deceit and racism. Unlike an election, there's no bolt hole in 5 years time, no opportunity to rest, recuperate and then resume the political fight. Instead I'm just left hollow, shattered and in utter shock at what's happened and how we got here.

Yesterday I was a member of one of the largest groupings of nations voluntarily coming together in history. Yes it was flawed, but I was proud to be a European citizen.

Today, everyone who ever mocked England for being stuck in the past and obsessed with faded glory was proven right. It honestly feels like my future has been stolen, in a way no general election ever has come close too.
 
Personal bit.

I've been through many elections in my life. Some were triumphs where it felt like the entire country was coming together in one voice - 1997. Some were sad gasps of despair where I honestly wondered how we could be here - 2015.

But none have ever hit me like the EU referendum result. I'm going to borrow the language of the right wing here - I honestly don't feel like this is my country anymore, and I want it back. We've made a decision that fundamentally alters everything about our place in the world and our future based on lies, deceit and racism. Unlike an election, there's no bolt hole in 5 years time, no opportunity to rest, recuperate and then resume the political fight. Instead I'm just left hollow, shattered and in utter shock at what's happened and how we got here.

Yesterday I was a member of one of the largest groupings of nations voluntarily coming together in history. Yes it was flawed, but I was proud to be a European citizen.

Today, everyone who ever mocked England for being stuck in the past and obsessed with faded glory was proven right. It honestly feels like my future has been stolen, in a way no general election ever has come close too.
I really feel for you.

Your right to be a European were basically stolen from you.

It would be horrible if today I woke up and learned my freedom of movement was stolen.

I think to the Erasmus friends I met when I studied in Spain. And how this kind of fraternity is a risk. Is sad that this has happened.
 
CluJUxjWEAAZEWM.jpg:large


Good statement.
 

PowerTaxi

Banned
Personal bit.

I've been through many elections in my life. Some were triumphs where it felt like the entire country was coming together in one voice - 1997. Some were sad gasps of despair where I honestly wondered how we could be here - 2015.

But none have ever hit me like the EU referendum result. I'm going to borrow the language of the right wing here - I honestly don't feel like this is my country anymore, and I want it back. We've made a decision that fundamentally alters everything about our place in the world and our future based on lies, deceit and racism. Unlike an election, there's no bolt hole in 5 years time, no opportunity to rest, recuperate and then resume the political fight. Instead I'm just left hollow, shattered and in utter shock at what's happened and how we got here.

Yesterday I was a member of one of the largest groupings of nations voluntarily coming together in history. Yes it was flawed, but I was proud to be a European citizen.

Today, everyone who ever mocked England for being stuck in the past and obsessed with faded glory was proven right. It honestly feels like my future has been stolen, in a way no general election ever has come close too.

:(

Got any Irish grandparents?
 

thefro

Member
No Defcon 5 in the treasury/finance department here, so I think we're going to be fine. Seems pretty calm actually.

But none have ever hit me like the EU referendum result. I'm going to borrow the language of the right wing here - I honestly don't feel like this is my country anymore, and I want it back. We've made a decision that fundamentally alters everything about our place in the world and our future based on lies, deceit and racism. Unlike an election, there's no bolt hole in 5 years time, no opportunity to rest, recuperate and then resume the political fight. Instead I'm just left hollow, shattered and in utter shock at what's happened and how we got here.

That's how a lot of us felt after 2004 in the US and then we had a wave election towards the Dems in 2006/2008. People were writing stuff about a "permanent Republican majority" then. The left will bounce back.
 

Maledict

Member
We won't be in Europe though. As horrible as it is at the time, you can always survive a national government - I remember 1992 and everyone's shock at the surprise result. But that can't happen here, unless something changes *rapidly* in our political scene and that's incredibly unlikely. We are out of Europe, and probably for the remainder of my l;I've given how long it takes to rejoin and how difficult it is and how opposed large swathes of the country are to it.

There is no come back - it really is a one shot call.
 
No Defcon 5 in the treasury/finance department here, so I think we're going to be fine. Seems pretty calm actually.



That's how a lot of us felt after 2004 in the US and then we had a wave election towards the Dems in 2006/2008. People were writing stuff about a "permanent Republican majority" then. The left will bounce back.

Defcon 5 is the most relaxed state of things.

I think you mean Defcon 1.
 

pigeon

Banned
I mean, saying I'll vote for Hillary and all my supporters should too is an endorsement, so basically Bernie endorsed today, everything's fine with old dude now.

I am amazed that Trump took credit for Brexit even as the economic calamity continued. For a rich guy he does not follow the stock market.
 
Wait, Bernie's team thinks they get a say on VP? Are they insane?

I feel like these people's mindsets should be "oh god I need to look for a job," not "Hillary isn't running her vp choices by us? Who the hell does Hillary think she is? The winner of the Democratic primary or something?"
 
No Defcon 5 in the treasury/finance department here, so I think we're going to be fine. Seems pretty calm actually.



That's how a lot of us felt after 2004 in the US and then we had a wave election towards the Dems in 2006/2008. People were writing stuff about a "permanent Republican majority" then. The left will bounce back.

They can't bounce back in to the EU. This wasn't some vote that can be fixed in the next election. This is permanent.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
I mean, saying I'll vote for Hillary and all my supporters should too is an endorsement, so basically Bernie endorsed today, everything's fine with old dude now.

I am amazed that Trump took credit for Brexit even as the economic calamity continued. For a rich guy he does not follow the stock market.

He just counts on his supporters not following it, which they likely don't.
 

andthebeatgoeson

Junior Member
He's a spineless coward who is also an idiot. Also he's resigned.

Sorry, any specifics? Stupid american here. Spineless in relation to the brexit vote? Or to immigration? Or to the rights push for this vote?


What the fuck is wrong with the internet, that it becomes listed next to immigration or any of those things? Not to say immigration is bad but how is it even related?

Or is this like a standard candle to tell you how stupid people are?
 

Fuchsdh

Member
There was this girl on the BBC World Service on my NPR station a few minutes ago that basically proved that young people are stupid everywhere, not just in the US. Shit like this was falling out of her mouth:

"Young people's votes should count more than older people because our turnout is lower, we should count as two or more votes each"

"Campaigns didn't target us enough to get us out."

"Alot of my friends do art and stuff and don't pay attention to this kind of thing and just assumed everything would turn out ok."

Completely eye-roll enducing.

That's why I won't believe Clinton has this in the bag until I see the actual results. Our generation is a bunch of dumbasses. Never underestimate their ability to whine about the system they don't actually partake in is failing to serve them.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Sorry, any specifics? Stupid american here. Spineless in relation to the brexit vote? Or to immigration? Or to the rights push for this vote?

Yes. To everything but the immigration thing.

He never should have promised this vote in the first place and instead of falling on the grenade and saving the entire UK from themselves he just bolted.

David Cameron RESIGNED? lol!

He was done the second the BBC called it for leave. Odds are we're going to see Boris as PM, god have mercy on their souls.
 
How do we get back to the general optimism and expansionary globalism of the post war-era.

I still believe these events are mostly a reaction to the 08-09 crisis but its getting harder and harder to see how the EU, UN, and other supranational forces regain the confidence of voters.


Young people are the only ones who are generally optimistic. Poling bares this out, we want to be engaged in the world while old people are just frightened. You see this everywhere. Bernie supporters, Brexit, Podemos, etc. While old people are going trump, leave the EU, Conservative in the Uk, etc.
 

Iolo

Member
I mean, saying I'll vote for Hillary and all my supporters should too is an endorsement, so basically Bernie endorsed today, everything's fine with old dude now.

His campaign team followed up and said it wasn't an endorsement.

Like Republicans saying Trump will get their vote but not their endorsement.

Because Hillary is apparently just that bad.

David Cameron RESIGNED? lol!

There was never any question of this.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
I didn't know this. I thought he would have weathered the storm the best he could, not show up with a suitcase in his hand after fucking the country and announcing, "She's all yours, Boris."

He put all his chips on remain and was fighting off an insurgency in his own party. Dude played the game of thrones poorly.
 

andthebeatgoeson

Junior Member
Just for that, maybe I'll vote trump just to spite you?

He's not lying. Bernie lost all credit. He should have STFU for a good month. And considering his terrible timing, announcing his Hillary support during the Brexit craziness was the best timing for him in about 6 months. He riled his supporters up over the past 2 months and let out a wimper today. The whole world is looking elsewhere. That does nothing for Hillary or progress or the election.

Now, Hillary is up 6 or 7, no one cares and his timing reinforces it. God, he's a damn dumpster fire too. Ignored principles for the NFL PR approach. Brexit is bigger but game 7 of the NBA finals also seems like a good time.
 

Rebel Leader

THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
He's not lying. Bernie lost all credit. He should have STFU for a good month. And considering his terrible timing, announcing his Hillary support during the Brexit craziness was the best timing for him in about 6 months. He riled his supporters up over the past 2 months and let out a wimper today. The whole world is looking elsewhere. That does nothing for Hillary or progress or the election.

Now, Hillary is up 6 or 7, no one cares and his timing reinforces it. God, he's a damn dumpster fire too. Ignored principles for the NFL PR approach. Brexit is bigger but game 7 of the NBA finals also seems like a good time.

I know that, there was a hidden message in the email quotes
 

Mael

Member
As a French guy this whole Brexit really put in perspective that De Gaulle was right in not wanting the UK into the CEE at the time.
If the UK pull the trigger and want back in they'll have hell to pay for the risk they've brought to the UE.
 

Maledict

Member
As a French guy this whole Brexit really put in perspective that De Gaulle was right in not wanting the UK into the CEE at the time.
If the UK pull the trigger and want back in they'll have hell to pay for the risk they've brought to the UE.

I would argue the opposite.

De Gaulles opposition, and vetoing, of the UK entry into the CEE was the bedrock of a lot of EU hostility from the UK from my grandparents generation. Had the UK joined when it first applied, and been part of the process much earlier on, I honestly feel that we wouldn't be here now.
 

ampere

Member
Many minorities voted Leave, including the British Afro-Caribbean community (the largest UK black community). Minority communities worry about immigration because new immigrants tend to compete with them rather than British workers. You can't apply American tropes to British politics like that.

I'll admit that my statement may be overly simplistic when applied to the UK, but it's at least true that if the US were made up of more white people we'd be much more likely to elect Trump so I'm glad we're not.
 

Mael

Member
I would argue the opposite.

De Gaulles opposition, and vetoing, of the UK entry into the CEE was the bedrock of a lot of EU hostility from the UK from my grandparents generation. Had the UK joined when it first applied, and been part of the process much earlier on, I honestly feel that we wouldn't be here now.

Well yeah but it was De Gaulle, if there's one thing you have to remember at the time is that their foreign policy wasn't going to be dictated by the US if they could help it.
In that way it was vital that the CEE was independent from US policy which the UK was threatening (at least in the mind of the French diplomacy).
If the whole thing was to end this way, they might as well have not joined at all.
If UK is out they're not coming back without serious commitment on their part.
And for all the anti-immigration British people this is a downright nightmare, France is in an even more advantageous position if they just want to ship immigrant to the other side of the border and let the UK deal with their shit.
 

sphagnum

Banned
How do we get back to the general optimism and expansionary globalism of the post war-era.

I still believe these events are mostly a reaction to the 08-09 crisis but its getting harder and harder to see how the EU, UN, and other supranational forces regain the confidence of voters.


Young people are the only ones who are generally optimistic. Poling bares this out, we want to be engaged in the world while old people are just frightened. You see this everywhere. Bernie supporters, Brexit, Podemos, etc. While old people are going trump, leave the EU, Conservative in the Uk, etc.

There is no solution other than time.

Internationalist socialism
 

pigeon

Banned
His campaign team followed up and said it wasn't an endorsement.

Like Republicans saying Trump will get their vote but not their endorsement.

Because Hillary is apparently just that bad.

Yeah, but they're wrong. I think he just endorsed her accidentally, it's a Kinsley gaffe. Obviously I'll vote for Hillary no matter what happens. Wait, what do you mean I endorsed her? That would ruin my leverage!


On Brexit, Josh Barro has the hot take that the biggest geopolitical danger today is voters voting for geopolitical danger out of anxiety.

I think this is true but it's also very worrying, because, like, there's nothing we can do about it if our country democratically chooses to suffer. Ultimately, although the global economy has recovered quite a bit, it is still true that the fundamentals nearly everywhere are basically poor. We're living through a Lost Generation right now -- it even started with a liquidity trap -- and nobody really seems to know what to do about it.

It's hard to be satisfied with kicking the can down the road*, but ultimately all the alternatives are worse. How do we sell "let's very slowly think about how to solve this problem while people suffer but probably less than they would otherwise suffer"** as the best possible choice?


* Hillary 2016
** Hillary 2016
 

pigeon

Banned
Is there even an alt-left movement analogous to alt-right? What does that look like?

I'm a third-way Democrat and have been for a while. I just am overly apologetic for authoritarians.

There is no formal alt-left movement, I just made it up for you. Although there are a lot of people, especially post-Brexit, who seem to have the basic position that the biggest threat to a free and equal society is democracy, which sounds pretty alt-left to me.

Most of them have not gone to the level of proposing benevolent military dictators in order to protect people's civil rights, but that just means you can be the leader.
 

Iolo

Member
Y
It's hard to be satisfied with kicking the can down the road*, but ultimately all the alternatives are worse. How do we sell "let's very slowly think about how to solve this problem while people suffer but probably less than they would otherwise suffer"** as the best possible choice?

* Hillary 2016
** Hillary 2016

Clearly Tim "Steel-Cut" Kaine is the answer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom