stuburns said:
It really depends on what you get out of the series I think. For me it's never been the battle system particularly, it's been the world, and just that level of polish they put in. The Final Fantasy games are always of the highest quality, and have such a richly imagined new world to explore. But, in recent years I've found it harder to be engrossed by the more high fantasy games, it's like I need them to be more grounded in reality for me to really get into them. FFVersusXIII certainly has that grounding, and I'm defiantly more excited about real-time action combat than the more traditional system in FFXIII. The game is just much more 'me' than the regular XIII.
Yeah, it's interesting that you bring that up; I don't think Final Fantasy games, in general, have appealed to me at all because of their combat systems. I could pick apart the last few, and certainly find aspects I like and dislike, but they never,
ever sell me on the product. In fact, chances are, they'll dissuade me from playing if anything (I didn't like FFXII's battle system, for example, while I found FFX's simple, elegant, and fun -- if maybe
too simple/formulaic at times).
I think I'm excited for FFXIII because, in the first time in a very, very long time, I'm okay with just accepting the high fantasy and reliving some of those teenage years of pure Final Fantasy joy that came with just saying "sure, I can buy into that." I loved FFX, and XIII seems very close in design and feel.
But FFversusXIII is immediately appealing to the older gamer in me. I want something more refined, more mature, perhaps a little more action-oriented, but I still want it to retain the classy nature of the FF games and the quality that always stems from them. "This is fantasy based on reality" -- it's going to be easier for my adult mind to buy into something like this, and so, without much work on my part, I think I'll be easily engrossed and entertained in this story.
As for which game will prove to be the best, that totally is up in the air. If FFversusXIII can provide a FF experience (ie: large scope, long play time, strong storyline, killer production values, and motivating characters/scenarios) while giving me a combat system I can sink my teeth into, it'll be a favorite. On the other hand, if it's "level based" connected by cutscenes and just doesn't have a lot of RPG-styled content (items, stores, exploration, etc, etc), FFXIII may win out.
Either way, I don't really have to choose between one or the other to own. They'll both be mine day one, so fuck it lol