ok, my analysis is done
i would love to post this in the pbe forums but i can't post on na cos my account is too low level so hoping costy might be nice enough to send this feedback to someone in charge of the star guardian lux texture adjustments
overall idea is i'm not super pleased with how the lux retexture looks. for starters, i don't think the original needed a change, it's a recent skin that looks great, blends in with the environment well but still pops out, has colors that are both bright and pleasing to the eye, it's a great skin. it's my favorite skin in the game, i love it
the retexture aims to make the skin pop a lot more. they essentially upped the contrast and saturation and sharpened the texture and while that works in some places (the star on her ribbon looks a lot better), i find it makes the skin overall look much worse.
instead of a soft pink her hair is now really intensely saturated. her skin is now really bright and looks unhealthy and plastic. her skirt is a really dark purple now that contrasts a lot with her shirt, so it draws more attention that you would hope for from the main part you should be looking about her which is her chest area and her hair and her staff, as in her main hitboxes and indicators of her actions
the skin is now too loud and sharp, it's no longer got that nice smooth look to it i liked so much
i love pink as a color because it's very easy on the eyes, you can just rest your gaze on it and you don't get tired. this is anything but, that plastic magenta hair is giving me a headache
and when i was zoomed in i thought ok this is just focusing too much on details you won't really care about in-game, but honestly i think zoomed out it's even worse. it just looks bad mixed with the background, and while it pops out more i really don't think the old textures had that problem. just look at the color of her skin and how visually arresting her palette is now compared to before
but if rito thinks that she wasn't popping out enough, i'm hoping there's a middle ground that can be reached that's less intense than this (which in all honestly looks like a 5min photoshop) that achieves both better clarity and visually pleasing
cos honestly if not i think my favorite skin in the game just got downgraded. the homeguard animation is ok i guess but doesn't make up for it looking worse at all moments of the game